Videokarma.org

Go Back   Videokarma.org TV - Video - Vintage Television & Radio Forums > Rectangular Screen Tube Televisions

Notices

We appreciate your help

in keeping this site going.
Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 06-23-2009, 04:49 PM
N9ZQA's Avatar
N9ZQA N9ZQA is offline
VK Member
 
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: Joliet, Illinois
Posts: 161
The switch to digital only affects BROADCAST television. Cable companies are not required to switch to digital transmission, although some are taking advantage of the media hype over DTV to move in that direction.

I'm not sure what the regulations are regarding the use of the -DT suffix on a station's callsign.

"Digital cable" uses QAM modulation instead of 8VSB as ATSC does for over-the-air transmission. You are correct in that digital cable viewers require a set-top box to decode the digital signal to either RF, composite video, or some other form of display interface technology - the same as using the converter box to receive over-the-air broadcasts.

As I understand it, the analog feeds on the cable of the local channels are done with a slightly heavier-duty version of the set-top converter boxes we've come to know and love. There may be other methods, but I'm not aware of any at the moment. Would love to hear if anyone has further info.

However, since cable television is brought to you on - just that - a cable, there is no requirement for them to use either analog or digital. The signals transmitted down that cable do not exist to the outside world (at least on a good day), so the cable company can send digital signals as well as analog NTSC signals. The advantage to them is that they can pack multiple digital signals into the bandwidth occupied by 1 analog channel. These signals are all RF, just different types of modulation - much like 10M AM and FM - same frequency, same intrinsic information transmitted, but completely different modulation schemes.

-Jim

Last edited by N9ZQA; 06-23-2009 at 04:54 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 06-23-2009, 07:27 PM
Jeffhs's Avatar
Jeffhs Jeffhs is offline
<----Zenith C845
 
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Fairport Harbor, Ohio (near Lake Erie)
Posts: 4,035
Quote:
Originally Posted by N9ZQA View Post
The switch to digital only affects BROADCAST television. Cable companies are not required to switch to digital transmission, although some are taking advantage of the media hype over DTV to move in that direction.

I'm not sure what the regulations are regarding the use of the -DT suffix on a station's callsign.

"Digital cable" uses QAM modulation instead of 8VSB as ATSC does for over-the-air transmission. You are correct in that digital cable viewers require a set-top box to decode the digital signal to either RF, composite video, or some other form of display interface technology - the same as using the converter box to receive over-the-air broadcasts.

As I understand it, the analog feeds on the cable of the local channels are done with a slightly heavier-duty version of the set-top converter boxes we've come to know and love. There may be other methods, but I'm not aware of any at the moment. Would love to hear if anyone has further info.

However, since cable television is brought to you on - just that - a cable, there is no requirement for them to use either analog or digital. The signals transmitted down that cable do not exist to the outside world (at least on a good day), so the cable company can send digital signals as well as analog NTSC signals. The advantage to them is that they can pack multiple digital signals into the bandwidth occupied by 1 analog channel. These signals are all RF, just different types of modulation - much like 10M AM and FM - same frequency, same intrinsic information transmitted, but completely different modulation schemes.

-Jim

I think you are missing my point. I am wondering how I can get my local channels without a converter box (my cable is connected more or less directly to my television--I say more or less because I have a VCR and a DVD player) if they are not standard television signals. This entire digital TV system has me baffled, and I don't know to this day what all the fuss was about (changing the date from 02.17 to 06.12 and all the other rigamarole that stood in the way of the thing, not to mention all the worrying the FCC did over people not being ready for the transition), as I cannot see the difference in the picture on my set.

The government should have left the old reliable NTSC system alone, as DTV, at least in its early stages, is proving to be more trouble than it is worth for a lot of viewers. I recently read in an e-mail newsletter from Broadcasting&Cable that the ABC television station in Philadelphia had to apply to the FCC for some sort of temporary permission to increase their signal so that it would "reach the fringes", whatever that means. (If viewers are having problems getting that channel or any other in digital, put up an antenna, as people used to do when color television arrived in this country in the 1960s and before there was such a thing as cable.)

I remember when "WDTV" was the call sign of a television station in West Virginia, and meant nothing more. Now, lop off the W and we have the abbreviation for a television standard that has all but turned television as we know it upside down. People are being all but forced to get cable because they can no longer get their area's local stations with an ordinary aerial, as they had been used to for over five decades. I still cannot get used to the idea that my own TV will not work without cable. I've had to downgrade my cable service to Time-Warner's basic level (local channels only) and really do miss being able to get my TV with an aerial. The FCC really blew it this time.

Over and out.
__________________
Jeff, WB8NHV

Collecting, restoring and enjoying vintage Zenith radios since 2002

Zenith. Gone, but not forgotten.
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 06-23-2009, 07:44 PM
MelodyMaster's Avatar
MelodyMaster MelodyMaster is offline
78s Galore.
 
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Mississauga, Ont, Canada
Posts: 86
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jeffhs View Post
I think you are missing my point. I am wondering how I can get my local channels without a converter box

The government should have left the old reliable NTSC system alone, as DTV, at least in its early stages, is proving to be more trouble than it is worth The FCC really blew it this time.

Over and out.
Analog TV in general is 80 years OLD! Think of that. Even the current NTSC scanning standards were codified in 1946. We have to move on. Everything else is digital, not that that's necessarily a good thing. But with the population of the planet and bandwidth requirements to feed that population being what it is, the much more efficient use of bandwidth provided by digital rather than analog is now a necessity.

Baseband cable is still analog, the cable provider uses digital receivers for the front end and converts the signal to standard NTSC for old fashioned viewers like yourself.

High Definition TV is very pretty, a movie screen in your home. If you had a digital set and convertor you wouldn't raise these questions. Of course there will be hiccups over such a radical change in technology.

Why shouldn't they add the suffix "-DT" for their Digital service? After all, stations have long used the suffix "-TV" to distinguish between television and radio service.

Last edited by MelodyMaster; 06-23-2009 at 07:48 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 07-01-2009, 11:07 PM
Jeffhs's Avatar
Jeffhs Jeffhs is offline
<----Zenith C845
 
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Fairport Harbor, Ohio (near Lake Erie)
Posts: 4,035
The DTV transition isn't over yet

Quote:
Originally Posted by MelodyMaster View Post
Analog TV in general is 80 years OLD! Think of that. Even the current NTSC scanning standards were codified in 1946. We have to move on. Everything else is digital, not that that's necessarily a good thing. But with the population of the planet and bandwidth requirements to feed that population being what it is, the much more efficient use of bandwidth provided by digital rather than analog is now a necessity.

Baseband cable is still analog, the cable provider uses digital receivers for the front end and converts the signal to standard NTSC for old fashioned viewers like yourself.

High Definition TV is very pretty, a movie screen in your home. If you had a digital set and convertor you wouldn't raise these questions. Of course there will be hiccups over such a radical change in technology.

Why shouldn't they add the suffix "-DT" for their Digital service? After all, stations have long used the suffix "-TV" to distinguish between television and radio service.
There are more so-called "old-fashioned" TV viewers in this country than you might think. Not everyone can afford a high-definition flat-panel TV and some cannot even afford a converter box. I am one of those who cannot afford a large flat-panel, although I could get a smaller set tomorrow if I wanted one with a 15" picture. There was an article in the paper here a week or so before the DTV transition in which a man in a suburb of a large U.S. city said that he could not afford a converter box for his old analog TV because he is on disability, which means he must now go to a friend's home if he wants to watch anything (even the news) on television.

Even those folks who can afford a converter box are not always able to hook up the box correctly or set it up, and some are incapable of understanding that an external antenna is required for proper operation of the box, despite the incessant warnings and everything else in the days and weeks leading up to the transition. The idea of disturbing the wiring in back of their televisions scares some people (they are afraid they might be shocked or killed by electricity on those cables) and puts off a lot of others. Most non-technical people do not know anything about their televisions other than how to turn them on and off, change channels, turn the volume up and down and mute the sound. Digital television has managed to thoroughly bamboozle these people, many of whom have no idea what DTV really is (and let's face it, most non-technical viewers couldn't care less about the behind-the-scenes side of digital)--despite all the PSAs (public service announcements) and print ads about the transition in the months leading up to it. I can imagine the scene in a lot of American living rooms from coast to coast the day after the transition, when they turn on their old (or not so old) analog television sets and see nothing but snow on every channel, even those channels which are supposed to be local to their areas. I can also imagine the large numbers of telephone calls TV repair shops across the land must have had up to closing time on 06.12 from people who found that they could not get their local TV channels anymore, and they wondered if the TV set was broken or if lightning had hit the antenna, the antenna itself was bad, etc.

The digital transition is still causing enough problems for some viewers in large cities such as Chicago and Philadelphia that the TV stations in those cities have applied to the FCC for temporary authority to increase their transmitter power, so their digital signals could reach viewers using antennas in far-suburban or fringe areas. I sometimes wonder why these people don't get cable or a better antenna, as it is not easy for a TV station to get FCC permission to do anything to its signal, and the stations certainly cannot simply raise their transmitter power on their own just because some small number of viewers in far suburbs or in the fringes out in the middle of nowhere are not getting them in digital. Most non-technical viewers do not understand that, thinking that all a TV station has to do is turn a knob on the transmitter and presto, the station will instantly reach from Maine to Miami with a city-grade digital signal.

We AKers know and respect this (that such a scenario as I just described is utterly impossible), but trying to explain this to most non-technical people will get you nowhere, in many cases. Many people will not get cable (even basic, what I call "bare-bones" basic, which is local channels only and is the lowest, least expensive level of service offered by all cable operators) because they claim it is too expensive. Don't try to sell these people on satellite, as you will probably get the same response (even though, in many cases, satellite is even cheaper than cable), possibly being followed by an adamant "No one's gonna put that ugly dish thingamajig on my house!"

What can you do? If someone can't afford or doesn't want cable or satellite, and doesn't understand why their TV doesn't work with just the antenna, there's nothing we can do. Many people refused to believe, in the last weeks of analog TV, that the day would come when their televisions would no longer operate with just an antenna connected, despite the warnings in the PSAs and even a few actual half-hour programs produced by the National Association of Broadcasters (NAB), detailing what viewers had to do to be ready for the digital transition on June 12 this year. A television station in Cleveland, a year or so before the transition and continuing until the bitter end, really pulled out all the stops to be as certain as humanly possible that everyone here in northeastern Ohio was aware of the digital transition by 06.12; its public-awareness campaign used the phrase The BIG SWITCH which showed on TV screens across the area, in letters darned nearly impossible to ignore; a banner carrying that phrase was shown, I swear, every chance the TV station got. I must say, I got tired of seeing this after just a short time (it ran on Cleveland's CBS affiliate and also on another local station owned by the same company) and am glad the whole thing is over. Except, that is, for the shouting, meaning the loose ends the FCC is still trying to tie up with reception problems and assisting those folks having trouble hooking up their converter boxes.
__________________
Jeff, WB8NHV

Collecting, restoring and enjoying vintage Zenith radios since 2002

Zenith. Gone, but not forgotten.

Last edited by Jeffhs; 07-01-2009 at 11:12 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 06-23-2009, 09:22 PM
andy andy is offline
VideoKarma Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2002
Posts: 4,004
000

Last edited by andy; 12-07-2021 at 05:41 PM.
Reply With Quote
Audiokarma
  #6  
Old 06-23-2009, 09:38 PM
Jeffhs's Avatar
Jeffhs Jeffhs is offline
<----Zenith C845
 
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Fairport Harbor, Ohio (near Lake Erie)
Posts: 4,035
Quote:
Originally Posted by andy View Post
It works because your cable system is still sending standard NTSC analog TV signals down the wire. These are the same type of signals that were used over the air, except they are sending them through a coaxial wire. The digital signals are on the same wire, but at a different frequency.

It's possible for analog and digital cable to share the same wire in much the same way analog and digital TV shared the same airwaves. They get along fine, as long as each channel is on a different frequency.
How can anyone still be transmitting analog when every television station in the US has turned off its analog signal? Television stations, and I think cable companies as well, are not allowed to transmit or otherwise use those signals anymore--it is all supposed to be digital or nothing as far as full-power television stations and cable companies are concerned. A lot of TV stations will find themselves in deep trouble with the FCC over this, and cable companies could find themselves in violation of some FCC statute as well for carrying analog TV signals.
__________________
Jeff, WB8NHV

Collecting, restoring and enjoying vintage Zenith radios since 2002

Zenith. Gone, but not forgotten.
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 06-23-2009, 10:02 PM
peverett peverett is offline
VideoKarma Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2002
Posts: 883
Andy is correct. Also, I do not know of any law forbidding the transmission of NTSC analog via cable TV. The DTV law applies to over the air broadcasting(and only to high power stations). I am sure that local stations can provide their analog signals to the cable companies via cable, not via broadcast. Since they are not broadcast, the cost will be very low.

At one time, I worked on an ADSL system where analog phone signals and high speed digital data signals were sent via the same pots(plain old telephone service) lines using different frequencys. Although complex, it worked fine.

In fact I get my analog TV, high speed internet, and telephone signal via one cable at present-no problems.
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old 06-24-2009, 12:09 AM
MelodyMaster's Avatar
MelodyMaster MelodyMaster is offline
78s Galore.
 
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Mississauga, Ont, Canada
Posts: 86
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jeffhs View Post
How can anyone still be transmitting analog when every television station in the US has turned off its analog signal? Television stations, and I think cable companies as well, are not allowed to transmit or otherwise use those signals anymore--it is all supposed to be digital or nothing as far as full-power television stations and cable companies are concerned. A lot of TV stations will find themselves in deep trouble with the FCC over this, and cable companies could find themselves in violation of some FCC statute as well for carrying analog TV signals.
Others have given much more detailed answers, but to sum up..

(1) The signal that is sent over cable is NOT in any way the same signal that is sent over the air by the station transmitter, it is a brand new signal originated by the cable company, in whatever standard best serves the customer. Since this doesn't "Radiate" it is not regulated by the FCC. Though of course there are standards for channel numbering etc.

(2) The cable company generally doesn't even PICK UP the signal over the air, but by some closed-circuit means such as microwave or fibre, so whatever format the broadcaster uses is irrelevant to the cable company. However, if baseband/closed circuit reception is not available the cable companies have been already often been using the broadcasters' digital service for reception rather than analog, because the quality is better.

Satellite is just the same, it picks up the station, then retransmits it using its own methods, then the customer has a box to convert it to what the customer's TV needs, which has generally been VHF RF, if not composite or component video.
Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old 06-23-2009, 10:56 PM
N9ZQA's Avatar
N9ZQA N9ZQA is offline
VK Member
 
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: Joliet, Illinois
Posts: 161
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jeffhs View Post
I think you are missing my point. I am wondering how I can get my local channels without a converter box (my cable is connected more or less directly to my television--I say more or less because I have a VCR and a DVD player) if they are not standard television signals. This entire digital TV system has me baffled, and I don't know to this day what all the fuss was about (changing the date from 02.17 to 06.12 and all the other rigamarole that stood in the way of the thing, not to mention all the worrying the FCC did over people not being ready for the transition), as I cannot see the difference in the picture on my set.
The signals your television is receiving are analog NTSC signals. Your cable company has decided to continue sending analog signals down the wire for viewers with cable-ready television sets. You won't see any difference on your set because there is simply none to see.

The following is from the Time-Warner cable web page:

Question:
If I’m a Basic (analog) cable customer, do I have to sign up for Digital Cable?

Answer:
No. Any Basic Cable setup will do. However, now is a good time to consider upgrading to Digital Cable, which offers more channels, as well as On Demand Programming, a free upgrade to HD service, an interactive program guide and more.

There is no law requiring the cable companies to switch to digital transmission. Doing so would be strictly a business decision - increased revenue from renting digital set-top boxes, as well as the ability to fit several digital channels into the space formerly occupied by one analog. However, they would risk losing many customers, who, like yourself are watching television on an analog set simply plugged into the wall.

-Jim
Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old 06-24-2009, 12:08 AM
peverett peverett is offline
VideoKarma Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2002
Posts: 883
One thing that always irritates me is when people like Melodymaster indicate that DTV is SO much more modern and better than analog. This is not necessarily the case.

For one thing, the digital signal is much less reliable in poor weather than the analog signal was. This so called "free bandwidth" obtained from the transition was not actually free. When we gave this up, we also gave up the reliability of our analog TV system. We did gain some things-HDTV(in good reception conditions), some emergency system bandwith(as well as a bunch of bandwidth-90% is my understanding-sold by the government to people like Verizon so they can sell it back to us at a higher prices).

I am not at all convinced that this transition was actually a good deal for the American consumer.

Remember that AM radio is around 90 years old and FM is around 75 years old. I do not see these systems going away any time soon.

FYI-I have a DTV and serveral converter boxes of different brands, these do nothing but re-inforce my observations.
Reply With Quote
Audiokarma
  #11  
Old 06-24-2009, 12:20 AM
MelodyMaster's Avatar
MelodyMaster MelodyMaster is offline
78s Galore.
 
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Mississauga, Ont, Canada
Posts: 86
Quote:
Originally Posted by peverett View Post
One thing that always irritates me is when people like Melodymaster indicate that DTV is SO much more modern and better than analog. This is not necessarily the case.

For one thing, the digital signal is much less reliable in poor weather than the analog signal was. This so called "free bandwidth" obtained from the transition was not actually free. When we gave this up, we also gave up the reliability of our analog TV system. We did gain some things-HDTV(in good reception conditions), some emergency system bandwith(as well as a bunch of bandwidth-90% is my understanding-sold by the government to people like Verizon so they can sell it back to us at a higher prices).

I am not at all convinced that this transition was actually a good deal for the American consumer.

Remember that AM radio is around 90 years old and FM is around 75 years old. I do not see these systems going away any time soon.

FYI-I have a DTV and serveral converter boxes of different brands, these do nothing but re-inforce my observations.
AM and FM radio do not take up the massive amounts of bandwidth used by VHF and UHF TV. The overwhelming majority of "easy" spectrum space is used just by broadcast television, with everything from emergency use through cellphones and over the air broadband internet squeezed into little spots between TV channels. There's an easy alternative to freeing up that space, eliminate 90% of the population...thus less communication bandwidth needed.

I should mention that I am an antique TV collector, with some nice mid to late 1940s sets, and a rare 1956 colour model that's listed with the antique television museum, so I'm sympathetic to analog methods. I'm simply stating that it's a fact of life and modern civilization that we have to go digital. We can't hang on, any more than we should still be producing 78s, which I also collect...

The FCC chose the method with the worst fringe-area recovery. Other methods could have caused an increase in macroblocks while retaining an image, the digital version of a snowy picture, but for reasons I forget they chose the ATSC method that they did.

It's the transition that hurts; do you think that if we waited another ten years there's be any less fuss? Meanwhile the limitations of analog TV will have become even MORE blatant while bandwidth for other communication uses will be even more starved.

Last edited by MelodyMaster; 06-24-2009 at 12:26 AM.
Reply With Quote
  #12  
Old 06-28-2009, 07:24 PM
NowhereMan 1966's Avatar
NowhereMan 1966 NowhereMan 1966 is offline
Slave to 1 Cat
 
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Tiltonsville, OH
Posts: 888
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jeffhs View Post
I think you are missing my point. I am wondering how I can get my local channels without a converter box (my cable is connected more or less directly to my television--I say more or less because I have a VCR and a DVD player) if they are not standard television signals. This entire digital TV system has me baffled, and I don't know to this day what all the fuss was about (changing the date from 02.17 to 06.12 and all the other rigamarole that stood in the way of the thing, not to mention all the worrying the FCC did over people not being ready for the transition), as I cannot see the difference in the picture on my set.

The government should have left the old reliable NTSC system alone, as DTV, at least in its early stages, is proving to be more trouble than it is worth for a lot of viewers. I recently read in an e-mail newsletter from Broadcasting&Cable that the ABC television station in Philadelphia had to apply to the FCC for some sort of temporary permission to increase their signal so that it would "reach the fringes", whatever that means. (If viewers are having problems getting that channel or any other in digital, put up an antenna, as people used to do when color television arrived in this country in the 1960s and before there was such a thing as cable.)

I remember when "WDTV" was the call sign of a television station in West Virginia, and meant nothing more. Now, lop off the W and we have the abbreviation for a television standard that has all but turned television as we know it upside down. People are being all but forced to get cable because they can no longer get their area's local stations with an ordinary aerial, as they had been used to for over five decades. I still cannot get used to the idea that my own TV will not work without cable. I've had to downgrade my cable service to Time-Warner's basic level (local channels only) and really do miss being able to get my TV with an aerial. The FCC really blew it this time.

Over and out.
BTW, WDTV used to be a Pittsburgh station on the old Dumont network. It started in 1949 on channel 3 and it was moved to channel 2 to stop interfering with Cleveland, OH. The station was sold and it became KDKA-TV ever since.
__________________
Mom (1938 - 2013) - RIP, I miss you
Spunky, (1999 - 2016) - RIP, pretty girl!
Rascal, (2007 - 2021) RIP, miss you very much
Reply With Quote
Reply


Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:28 AM.



Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
©Copyright 2012 VideoKarma.org, All rights reserved.