View Single Post
  #24  
Old 02-05-2009, 11:33 AM
Jeffhs's Avatar
Jeffhs Jeffhs is offline
<----Zenith C845
 
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Fairport Harbor, Ohio (near Lake Erie)
Posts: 4,035
Quote:
Originally Posted by AUdubon5425 View Post
My main beef with all of this is that I'll no longer be able to place my little portable Philco-Ford wherever I want to watch it without lugging a bunch of cables & the converter box with it. For me it defeats the whole purpose of having a "portable" TV.
I think there are portable TVs, not to mention VCRs and DVD recorders, with ATSC tuners available now--in fact, I'm all but sure of it, since stores are no longer permitted to sell new-in-box analog TVs with NTSC tuners; the only exceptions would be sets sold without tuners of any kind (for use only with line-input signals from OTA or cable converters, VCRs and DVD players) or the case of stores wanting to sell off their inventory of analog NTSC sets in a hurry. In the latter case, however, there must be a clearly worded notice, either on the set itself or in the instruction manual (or both), stating that the TV will not work after the digital transition unless it is connected to a converter box or to cable or satellite service. The notice must also clearly state that the set will continue to operate with VCRs, DVD players, and video game consoles, with no modifications required.

There is presently, however, no such requirement for analog NTSC TVs sold on eBay or Craigslist, that I am aware of. I think there should be; that is, sellers of used NTSC televisions must clearly state that the sets won't work after the transition without cable, satellite or an OTA converter. There are still many people who are completely unprepared for the transition and/or do not understand that their sets will no longer work with antennas after the analog stations go off the air. The scenario depicted in a Youtube video I saw a few weeks ago, in which an elderly woman is trying, unsuccessfully, to connect an OTA ATSC converter box to her old analog TV, is anything but unheard of; many people are baffled by the maze of wires behind their TV, and will not touch them under any circumstances.

If ATSC OTA converters were truly "plug and play" devices, such problems would not be issues today. I can only guess how often the very same scenario played out when UHF television converters first came on the market, leaving many viewers baffled as to how the box was to be connected to the TV. ATSC converters seem to me to be no more complicated than a UHF converter to connect to any standard television. My best guess is that, in those days, many people just left their TVs alone and didn't bother with UHF until the old set quit; then they got a new all-channel TV. The only exception would have probably been viewers with older VHF-only sets in markets with only UHF TV stations, but in these markets new TVs were, after April 30, 1964, already factory-equipped with UHF tuners, converters being used with older sets.

The same rule applies to new televisions sold after February 1, 2007. These sets must have ATSC tuners. Unlike UHF-equipped sets that still had VHF NTSC tuners, however, the new generation of high- and standard-definition televisions have only ATSC tuners. There is no need for the old NTSC tuner, since after the transition (now 06.12.09), the NTSC television system in the US will have been abolished, having been replaced by 100-percent digital. In some markets, such as Hawaii (all markets in the entire state) and several markets in at least one state on the mainland, analog TV already has ended; others are sure to follow suit, even before the official transition date. I think at least one of the PBS stations here in northeastern Ohio (Time-Warner Cable in this area carries two PBS affiliates) already has made the switch; I will remain watchful for developments at the area's other eight TV stations, as the Cleveland stations have not yet (to the best of my knowledge) announced plans to end early their analog transmissions.
__________________
Jeff, WB8NHV

Collecting, restoring and enjoying vintage Zenith radios since 2002

Zenith. Gone, but not forgotten.
Reply With Quote