Like Mark, I haven't seen the particular ads you're mentioning. Ed, I do see your point, however, that a man should not be defined and described by the beer he drinks. That's getting into psychological issues like self-esteem, and self-awareness, the values in life that one holds sacred, and how one relates to others in a society. In that context, I do agree with you that the very concept of the ad campaign as described is idiotic. If you make ads for a living then you surely have some extra insight as to the messages that advertising tries to get across.

Tom