Videokarma.org

Go Back   Videokarma.org TV - Video - Vintage Television & Radio Forums > Early B&W and Projection TV

Notices

We appreciate your help

in keeping this site going.
Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 06-25-2020, 01:30 PM
Yamamaya42's Avatar
Yamamaya42 Yamamaya42 is online now
VideoKarma Member
 
Join Date: Nov 2018
Location: Round Rock TX
Posts: 3,252
I really fail to see what the point of all this discussion / contention is all about.
When it has been shown over and over again, (and there are many sites dedicated to this. ) that in the restoration of vintage electronics, decades old capacitors, electrolytic and paper, are inherently unreliable due to entropic degradation, and even though they may seem to work, they are like a time bomb waiting to go off, and best replaced with more modern ones which are smaller, and often will preform better and last longer than what is being replaced, especially if high tolerance long life type is used, and of slightly higher voltage range than the original.
And, as it has been pointed out more than once, these new caps can be stuffed into cans of the old, leaving the visual aesthetics unaffected, or, as in the case of my CTC-16XL, I just unhooked the old caps on the bottom, and placed the new ones various places under the chassis, from the top, you can't tell anything was replaced, and I chose the new caps very carefully, all high tolerance long life, if replacing 80uf @ 450v, I put in a 500v one, 20uf @ 250v = 300v , and so on.

It's MY choice not to risk things on old caps, and I'm sure others feel the same, but if you want to run your stuff with them, go right ahead!
__________________
=^-^=
Yasashii yoru ni hitori utau uta. Asu wa kimi to utaou. Yume no tsubasa ni notte.
いとおしい人のために
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 06-25-2020, 02:13 PM
init4fun's Avatar
init4fun init4fun is offline
VideoKarma Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2011
Posts: 1,210
I think the bottom line here is this ;

old capacitors are kinda like old people , some live a perfectly healthy life well into their 90s and some begin to seriously degrade starting in their 60s and don't make 70 . And when those people were young there really was no telling which would see the near century mark VS who'd be worm food by 60 . I'm sure there are those caps that'll live to a ripe old age performing their capacitor duties just fine without missing a beat just as there are plenty of them that are right now going to crap in 5 year old TVs , all the while their antique counterparts are still happily doing the cap thing without a whimper . It's luck of the draw , nothing more , and while I think it's great that those particular caps reformed well and came back to life I don't believe every , or maybe even every other , antique cap can be revived in such manner . As a cool experiment I think it's great that you had success but with the destructive nature of a shorted Ecap in mind I do systematically replace every one in any "daily driver" sets I run , just so that I can feel somewhat comfortable leaving them to run while I do things in other parts of the house without having to keep a literal eye on them

I , for one , am hoping to see your experiment run well into the hundreds of hours .....
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 06-25-2020, 06:20 PM
Penthode's Avatar
Penthode Penthode is offline
VideoKarma Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: Kitchener/Waterloo Ontario Canada
Posts: 1,463
Quote:
Originally Posted by init4fun View Post
I think the bottom line here is this ;

old capacitors are kinda like old people , some live a perfectly healthy life well into their 90s and some begin to seriously degrade starting in their 60s and don't make 70 . And when those people were young there really was no telling which would see the near century mark VS who'd be worm food by 60 . I'm sure there are those caps that'll live to a ripe old age performing their capacitor duties just fine without missing a beat just as there are plenty of them that are right now going to crap in 5 year old TVs , all the while their antique counterparts are still happily doing the cap thing without a whimper . It's luck of the draw , nothing more , and while I think it's great that those particular caps reformed well and came back to life I don't believe every , or maybe even every other , antique cap can be revived in such manner . As a cool experiment I think it's great that you had success but with the destructive nature of a shorted Ecap in mind I do systematically replace every one in any "daily driver" sets I run , just so that I can feel somewhat comfortable leaving them to run while I do things in other parts of the house without having to keep a literal eye on them

I , for one , am hoping to see your experiment run well into the hundreds of hours .....
Thanks for the comment. I sort of see that as well: some have a grand old age and others sadly die prematurely.

I think the success for a long life, both in human and electrolytic terms is to recognize the symptoms of disease early and address it. Some prefer milder treatment whereas others go for radical treatment. And continuing the comparison no one know absolutely for sure if the remedy will be effective or not.

The set now appears very healthy and runs well after 50 hours in the last four days. No detectable hum, lots of clean audio and a sharp picture on my good 10BP4. And rechecking the leakage on one of the electrolytics,, it has dropped a further 80% in the last 50 hours.

Again this project is to satisfy my own personal interest in preserving as much originality in the 721TS as possible and should in no way dissuade you from replacing vintage electrolytics in your own equipment if you so desire. And if I were to leave the set unattended I would protect it by other means such as a fuse. But I am happy remain with the set while it is on.
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 06-25-2020, 06:38 PM
init4fun's Avatar
init4fun init4fun is offline
VideoKarma Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2011
Posts: 1,210
I'll easily agree that with better than 50 hours on it and the leakage continuing to drop that those caps have proven themselves at least in the short term . I really am hoping you get 100s of hours out of them because it would further your experiment and show that at least some do survive long term . I saw in your first post that you live in Canada and the set was stored in an attic . I know nothing about the general climate where you live so I'll ask , do attics there get Hell like hot in the summer like they do in the lower States of the US or is the climate cool enough there that the set wasn't subject to regular temperatures over 100 degrees (F) ? If the attic remained cool year round I'd bet that one difference likely made a world of difference in the condition of the caps VS a set stored the same amount of time in a Texas attic .
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 06-25-2020, 07:52 PM
Penthode's Avatar
Penthode Penthode is offline
VideoKarma Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: Kitchener/Waterloo Ontario Canada
Posts: 1,463
I actually bought the set in central NY near Schenectady. The was no TV in Canada until 1952 and the first available TV dighna l here was from WBEN TV Buffalo NY in 1948. Muy RCA 8T243 was allegedly the first Canadian built TV manufactured in Montreal Quebec.

I bought the 721TS from the house it was purchased for and sat in for over 65 years. The attic was insulated so I guess it did not get too warm in the summer nor too cold in the winter. The set is interesting as it was quite dirty but typical he chassis was not corroded.

I bought an RCA 8T271 which included survivor electrolytics from a home just outside Philadelphia 7 years ago. The original owner bought the set just after he left the US Army with a bonus and he retained it until his death at the age of 91 in 2013. His family sold it to me and despite it not working and sitting in a corner in ther house for nearly 60 years unused, the electrolytic capacitors all came back fine and are still okay after hundreds of hours. This set, having sat indoors its whole life, had a pristine chassis. It looks like new.

So you have to take each case as it comes, I guess.

Last edited by Penthode; 06-25-2020 at 07:57 PM.
Reply With Quote
Audiokarma
  #6  
Old 06-25-2020, 09:55 PM
Penthode's Avatar
Penthode Penthode is offline
VideoKarma Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: Kitchener/Waterloo Ontario Canada
Posts: 1,463
The 721TS is currently running and has reached 52 hours. Running some Popeye cartoons.

I grabbed a couple of electrolytics from a rusty old Fada 630TS chassis (cabinet dissolved into shards). Looks like it was stored in a wet shed outside. So the electrolytic will have suffered wide climatic changes.

I started reforming it at 4pm today. It is now 10:30pm and at 450 volts the 10uF and 40uF capacitors in the can connected in parallel show a leakage of 200uA. This shows the capacitor is good. The 40uF measures 45uF and the 10uF measures 15uF.

I have been told I am lucky. Maybe so but I never have won a contest or even a book at the local raffle. So this baffles me why I have so much success and everyone else has horror stories to relate.

With the reformed electrolytic with such low leakage at full capacitor rated voltage, before tearing it apart, I would like to leave it at the full 450 volts for a day to see what happens. I maybe will after over voltage by say 5% to see what happens. Fortunately the failure mode is predictable: when it starts to go, like the paper capacitors, there will be a thermal runaway where the leakage increases creatingvheat which further accelerates the leakage and so on. In a paper capacitor, there is little thermal lag so the paper capacitor thermal runaway is fairly fast. The larger electrolytic thermal runaway is slower and more manageable.

Here is a picture of the reformed 630TS capacitor. Notice the VTVM reads 450 Volts DC and the Sprague TO-6 reads 200uA on the 0.6 mA full scale range. And a picture off the 721TS on the weak 10BP4.
Attached Images
File Type: jpg 20200625_222125.jpg (95.0 KB, 37 views)
File Type: jpg 20200625_222819.jpg (58.9 KB, 52 views)

Last edited by Penthode; 06-25-2020 at 10:10 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 06-25-2020, 02:47 PM
Penthode's Avatar
Penthode Penthode is offline
VideoKarma Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: Kitchener/Waterloo Ontario Canada
Posts: 1,463
Quote:
Originally Posted by Yamamaya42 View Post
I really fail to see what the point of all this discussion / contention is all about.
When it has been shown over and over again, (and there are many sites dedicated to this. ) that in the restoration of vintage electronics, decades old capacitors, electrolytic and paper, are inherently unreliable due to entropic degradation..


It's MY choice not to risk things on old caps, and I'm sure others feel the same, but if you want to run your stuff with them, go right ahead!
Entropic degradation? I am curious what this is.

I am amused bt your comment "when it is shown over and over again". There is a lot of stuff on the internet by many self proclaimed experts. You have not attempted to test the process and I see you are not willing to accept the evidence I has provided. The set has been on now continuously for over six hours reaching a total of 50 hours and the electrolytic capacitors remain fine.

I am not disputing anyone who chooses to replace the electrolytics. However I am disconcerted by reading here that all capacitors including electrolytic, paper and mica should be blindly replaced.

It is amusing to see defensive reaction to my hobby specific activities. I do not disagree with you if yo prefer to replace the capacitors. I have refilled many electrolytic cans myself, most recently my HP DC power supply. I am only posting this information here to demonstrate to all how the capacitors can survive more than seven decades and still work.

I am going to look inside a reformed good capacitor to see what degradation has occurred. I would also suggest you try reforming an old capacitor properly and then testing it for yourself.

I abhor the practise of applying power or even use of a Variac on a set that has not been thoroughly vetted and corrected. It is fraught with danger and because these electronic devices rely upon oscillators to generated grid bias, will lead to other component failures.

Note in this case, I reformed the capacitors and made all the required component replacements after detailed analysis of the circuit before applying full power. This set came up immediately and worked without issues.
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old 06-25-2020, 03:22 PM
JohnCT's Avatar
JohnCT JohnCT is offline
VideoKarma Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2020
Posts: 749
Quote:
Originally Posted by Penthode View Post
I would also suggest you try reforming an old capacitor properly and then testing it for yourself.
I think you're assuming members of this forum haven't tried this. I won't speak for any other old timer here, but I have tried it as I mentioned in an earlier comment. What I discovered was that it was hit or miss, and therefore a waste of time when your name goes on a repair. Your example, although very interesting, won't change my experiences.

The Andrea I'm working on has a lot more hours than yours (I'd guess it's well over a hundred twenty five hours since February) and 5 of the cans are still good and operating fine, but history tells me that they're on bonus time. Using my own TV as an example, two cans were dead immediately, and two failed some 20-30 plus hours after it was running perfectly. The remaining 5 are still running fine at over a hundred hours. They're still coming out.

Sure, you can have capacitors work after 70 or more years, but proving a capacitor can work at 70 years and proving a capacitor can work for 15 hours a week for the next 10 years is another thing entirely.

I mentioned earlier that I'm restoring an 1850s reed organ melodeon. The leather exhauster is still working, but if don't replace the leather, how long will my wife be able to play the melodeon before the leather tears? 10 hours, 100 hours? Maybe she'll never put enough hours on it, but I'm replacing the leather anyway. Once this melodeon is finished, I don't want to ever take it apart again.

That's the point we're trying to make on this subject.

John

Last edited by JohnCT; 06-25-2020 at 03:32 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old 06-25-2020, 03:41 PM
Electronic M's Avatar
Electronic M Electronic M is offline
M is for Memory
 
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: Pewaukee/Delafield Wi
Posts: 15,496
Quote:
Originally Posted by JohnCT View Post
I think you're assuming members of this forum haven't tried this. I won't speak for any other old timer here, but I have tried it as I mentioned in an earlier comment. What I discovered was that it was hit or miss, and therefore a waste of time when your name goes on a repair. Your example, although very interesting, won't sway me at all.

The Andrea I'm working on has a lot more hours than yours (I'd guess it's well over a hundred twenty five hours since February) and 5 of the cans are still good operating fine, but history tells me that they're on bonus time. Using my own TV as an example, two cans were dead immediately, and two failed some 20-30 plus hours after it was running perfectly. The remaining 5 are still running fine at over a hundred hours. They're still coming out.

Sure, you can have capacitors work after 70 or more years, but proving a capacitor can work at 70 years and proving a capacitor can work for 15 hours a week for the next 10 years is another thing entirely.

I mentioned earlier that I'm restoring an 1850s reed organ melodeon. The leather exhauster is still working, but if don't replace the leather, how long will my wife be able to play the melodeon before the leather tears? 10 hours, 100 hours? Maybe she'll never put enough hours on it, but I'm replacing the leather anyway. Once this melodeon is finished, I don't want to ever take it apart again.

That's the point we're trying to make on this subject.

John
+1
I've also reformed and vetted lytics with my Heathkit and watched them fail after dozzens of hours of operation.

I've seen TVs and radios run on original caps and even keep a few that way as shelf queens that rarely get powered. Though even that isn't common since if I power on a display set and it dies on me it could be an embarrassment, and even if it isn't I rather feel confident I can grab anything off my shelf and run it as if I just bought it new without worry.

I put enough hours on my sets to go through certain tubes multiple times. Anything that will help put the next repair farther out into the future and let me tackle repairing something else or let me live my life away from the bench is worth doing.
__________________
Tom C.

Zenith: The quality stays in EVEN after the name falls off!
What I want. --> http://www.videokarma.org/showpost.p...62&postcount=4
Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old 06-25-2020, 06:04 PM
Penthode's Avatar
Penthode Penthode is offline
VideoKarma Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: Kitchener/Waterloo Ontario Canada
Posts: 1,463
Quote:
Originally Posted by Electronic M View Post
+1
I've also reformed and vetted lytics with my Heathkit and watched them fail after dozzens of hours of operation.
Well I have seen a bunch fail in service. And many have not passed the reforming process and test before putting into service. You have not explained what your criterion is. Instead you trash my observations.

And as as this to me is purely a hobby, if the component fails in service, it provides further enjoyment pulling the thing apart to service it because it is my hobby.

Maybe some of us should stop to reflect and chill out.
Reply With Quote
Audiokarma
  #11  
Old 06-26-2020, 10:42 AM
Electronic M's Avatar
Electronic M Electronic M is offline
M is for Memory
 
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: Pewaukee/Delafield Wi
Posts: 15,496
Quote:
Originally Posted by Penthode View Post
Well I have seen a bunch fail in service. And many have not passed the reforming process and test before putting into service. You have not explained what your criterion is. Instead you trash my observations.

And as as this to me is purely a hobby, if the component fails in service, it provides further enjoyment pulling the thing apart to service it because it is my hobby.

Maybe some of us should stop to reflect and chill out.
The process is simple: unsolder positive lead(s) of capacitor connect cap to Heathkit C3, check capacitance and if not open check leakage indication on tester at 50V if good select next higher range,if bad wait 2 minutes for signs of improvement if no change in reading or improvement stops change capacitor, if leakage drops to acceptible select higher voltage test range. If a capacitor tests as having acceptible leakage at full working voltage it gets ran in set for several hours and checked for temperature and possibly leakage again later.

Any more than this is well in excess of my patience, and after doing this process for a few years worth of restos I have stopped as I have come to the conclusion that it is a complete waste of my time over changing all capacitors of a type I know are prone to failure....on any chassis mount lytics once the positive is unhooked it is quicker to solder in a new part, the new parts are cheaper than the time I spend on a reforming, and the guarantee that a new production part isn't going to take out unobtainium for better than 25 years is worth more to me than original parts. I'm keeping the original tube circuits in and not shit canning them to install a flat screen and I usually keep the original removed caps in a bag with the set with a copy of the schematic and enough documentation that any future historian could analyze the original design and parts and put it back to stock if they wanted. That is as original as a working set has to be for me.
__________________
Tom C.

Zenith: The quality stays in EVEN after the name falls off!
What I want. --> http://www.videokarma.org/showpost.p...62&postcount=4

Last edited by Electronic M; 06-26-2020 at 10:45 AM.
Reply With Quote
  #12  
Old 06-25-2020, 05:58 PM
Penthode's Avatar
Penthode Penthode is offline
VideoKarma Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: Kitchener/Waterloo Ontario Canada
Posts: 1,463
Quote:
Originally Posted by JohnCT View Post

Sure, you can have capacitors work after 70 or more years, but proving a capacitor can work at 70 years and proving a capacitor can work for 15 hours a week for the next 10 years is another thing entirely.

John
I did mention I have a 1949 RCA 8T243 I acquired in 1970 and still runs on its original electrolytics. If I am fortunate to still be alive in 20 years, I will let you know if the capacitors are still okay.

And I generally do not watch 15 hours of TV. I the 721TS case, I simply left it running while going about other things.

I find it very amusing however how some members of this forum take the subject of electrolytic capacitor replacement so very seriously.
Reply With Quote
  #13  
Old 06-25-2020, 11:34 PM
Yamamaya42's Avatar
Yamamaya42 Yamamaya42 is online now
VideoKarma Member
 
Join Date: Nov 2018
Location: Round Rock TX
Posts: 3,252
Quote:
Originally Posted by Penthode View Post
Entropic degradation? I am curious what this is.

I am amused bt your comment "when it is shown over and over again". There is a lot of stuff on the internet by many self proclaimed experts. You have not attempted to test the process and I see you are not willing to accept the evidence I has provided. The set has been on now continuously for over six hours reaching a total of 50 hours and the electrolytic capacitors remain fine.

I am not disputing anyone who chooses to replace the electrolytics. However I am disconcerted by reading here that all capacitors including electrolytic, paper and mica should be blindly replaced.

It is amusing to see defensive reaction to my hobby specific activities. I do not disagree with you if yo prefer to replace the capacitors. I have refilled many electrolytic cans myself, most recently my HP DC power supply. I am only posting this information here to demonstrate to all how the capacitors can survive more than seven decades and still work.

I am going to look inside a reformed good capacitor to see what degradation has occurred. I would also suggest you try reforming an old capacitor properly and then testing it for yourself.

I abhor the practise of applying power or even use of a Variac on a set that has not been thoroughly vetted and corrected. It is fraught with danger and because these electronic devices rely upon oscillators to generated grid bias, will lead to other component failures.

Note in this case, I reformed the capacitors and made all the required component replacements after detailed analysis of the circuit before applying full power. This set came up immediately and worked without issues.

Entropy, a product of the second law of thermodynamics, was the slow, irreversible process of breakdown and decay whereby a complex, organized system inevitably degraded into more chaotic ones.
__________________
=^-^=
Yasashii yoru ni hitori utau uta. Asu wa kimi to utaou. Yume no tsubasa ni notte.
いとおしい人のために
Reply With Quote
Reply


Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:55 PM.



Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
©Copyright 2012 VideoKarma.org, All rights reserved.