Videokarma.org

Go Back   Videokarma.org TV - Video - Vintage Television & Radio Forums > Television Broadcast Theory

Notices

We appreciate your help

in keeping this site going.
Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 06-18-2020, 10:53 PM
old_tv_nut's Avatar
old_tv_nut old_tv_nut is offline
See yourself on Color TV!
 
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: Rancho Sahuarita
Posts: 7,815
Quote:
Originally Posted by etype2 View Post
Was there ever any 1953 NTSC color consumer or professional content based on the true NTSC Color Gamut and if so, are there photographs displaying the wide color gamut on a CRT?
I'm not sure what you mean by consumer content. In 1953 only professional cameras were available.

The original RCA TK-41 cameras were designed to come as close as possible to correct for driving a display with NTSC phosphors. Calculations based on spectral sensitivity measurements (rescued from loss at RCA) show this.
http://www.bretl.com/viewing1950scolor.htm
This was achieved with narrow-band optical filters and no electrical matrixing, as that would have brought on increased noise and stability problems. The result is that very slight adjustments in the color level and hue settings of a receiver/monitor would produce excellent color matches for common surface colors, better than any photographic film. However, the cameras also had less gamma correction than required to match the CRT gamma, resulting in increased contrast and color saturation. The cameras thus had a problem of limited dynamic range (as did the CRTs if viewed in a lighted room). The system was similar to Technicolor film in this regard, requiring reduced lighting ratios, substitution of grayed or light blue shirts for white, etc., along with very careful exposure adjustment to put the subjects in the middle of the gray scale.

Later cameras with less noisy pickup tubes and wider bandwidth color optics used electrical matrixing, but it was still set to NTSC specs at first. Meanwhile, display makers had adopted non-standard phosphors and electrical matrixing to keep the hue spread proper between red, yellow and green (and fleshtone). And while camera makers kept the matrix for NTSC at first, they also played with the color separation optics to get the best looking color on monitors, and eventually fudged things entirely to look good on more modern monitors, which had the new phosphors, but a matrix on/off switch. Which position of the switch was the camera fudged for? No one knows what a particular brand of camera did anymore, and it may have been a compromise. One of the glaring problems with the receiver/monitor matrix is that it exaggerated the brightness of reds and reduced subtle variations in them.

All the above mess happened with NTSC. With PAL, because it was established after the new phosphors were usual, the PAL camera optics and matrix was specified to get a proper match without the approximate electrical matrix in the receiver. This practice was incorporated in HDTV and the sRGB still picture standard for computers.

If your question is, is there any material available now that you could play on an early set with NTSC phosphors and know you are seeing NTSC color, the answer in some cases is probably not, and in other cases definitely not. You often can see the high contrast and noise of TK-41s in DVDs of old shows from the early 60s or earlier, but the color may or may not reflect the TK-41s accurately, depending on how much color correction was done in remastering, which of course would have been judged on a modern monitor.

Any of our favorite DVD or Blu-Ray movies for demonstrating old sets are far removed from NTSC. You may see the brilliant emerald greens, but there is no way of knowing if they are correct, because these have all been remastered for current receivers/monitors.

Quote:
Originally Posted by etype2 View Post
... are there photographs displaying the wide color gamut on a CRT?
No.
Color film could not reproduce the NTSC green. Modern monitors cannot reproduce it, and therefore digital photos generally do not reproduce it. As stated above, it is outside the sRGB color space. Thus, when you post jpg files to the web, the viewers really can't see an accurate reproduction of what you had on your NTSC screen.

If you put color bars on your old set, take a picture with a digital camera set to Adobe RGB or prophoto RGB, and display it on a wide-gamut monitor (or the old TV), then you should see the NTSC primaries and secondaries reproduced, sort of. There are many caveats about how the raw data is processed by the digital camera or raw-file processing program, all of which are fudged to get a preferred film-like reproduction rather than a colorimetrically accurate one. Still camera makers and Adobe tumbled to the fact that a film-like "S-curve" contrast response is greatly preferred over the older video camera gamma curve that clipped overexposed highlights.

What to do? Turn on your set, play whatever you like, adjust for best looking results, and enjoy.

I haven't looked lately to see if Photoshop and Lightroom have an NTSC monitor profile available, but if they do and you have an NTSC composite output on your computer, you could display stills from raw files that are close to correct. Failing that, Adobe RGB profile would be close in the reds and greens, but not so great in the blues.
__________________
www.bretl.com
Old TV literature, New York World's Fair, and other miscellany
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 06-19-2020, 12:47 AM
ppppenguin's Avatar
ppppenguin ppppenguin is offline
VideoKarma Member
 
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: London, UK
Posts: 466
That's a pretty comprehensive summary of the issue. The only thing missing is WHY the reference primaries were changed. AFAIK it's because the original NTSC phosphors resulted in pictures that weren't very bright. Newer phosphors were brighter but couldn't give the same range of colours. Since the new colour gamut was good enough it became the standard.

By the time of PAL and SECAM all this had more or less settled down. Not quite though. There was a set of EBU reference primaries that turned out to be expensive and/or hard to make as phosphors. So in practice most CRTs had slightly different primaries. AFAIK it was only a small difference and didn't really matter outside of very critical colour matching.
__________________
www.borinsky.co.uk Jeffrey Borinsky www.becg.tv
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 06-19-2020, 07:13 AM
etype2's Avatar
etype2 etype2 is offline
VideoKarma Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: Valley of the Sun, formerly Silicon Valley, formerly Packer Land.
Posts: 1,643
“‘If you put color bars on your old set, take a picture with a digital camera set to Adobe RGB or prophoto RGB, and display it on a wide-gamut monitor (or the old TV), then you should see the NTSC primaries and secondaries reproduced, sort of.”

THE COLOR BARS TODAY WOULD BE SMPTE C, RIGHT?

It’s interesting after 67 years, the original NTSC color gamut has not been exceeded. RCA had lofty goals in the design of the CT-100, then dumbed down later receivers. The consumer was never going to notice the difference and “brighter was better.” The 1953 NTSC color gamut was actually a format that was never used. Excellent paper

Edit: May I consider the color charts in your paper, especially green accurate 1953 NTSC colors? Like this one?https://visions4netjournal.com/wp-co...24396ECF8.jpeg
__________________

Last edited by etype2; 06-19-2020 at 08:05 AM.
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 06-19-2020, 10:38 AM
old_tv_nut's Avatar
old_tv_nut old_tv_nut is offline
See yourself on Color TV!
 
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: Rancho Sahuarita
Posts: 7,815
Quote:
Originally Posted by etype2 View Post
...

THE COLOR BARS TODAY WOULD BE SMPTE C, RIGHT?

...
Edit: May I consider the color charts in your paper, especially green accurate 1953 NTSC colors? Like this one?https://visions4netjournal.com/wp-co...24396ECF8.jpeg
If the color bars are generated as R, G, and B = 1(max) or 0, and passed through an NTSC (or PAL) encoder, the electrical composite signal will drive a TV with standard NTSC or PAL decoder to CRT drive values of 1(max) or 0, because the electrical chroma encoder and decoder for PAL was never changed from the NTSC spec. In other words, the Y, R-Y, and B-Y signal values and resulting subcarrier amplitude and phase of NTSC bars and PAL bars are identical, although each primary color is different.

This results in some differences in the brightness of the compatible black and white picture of saturated colors from a camera, but not from color bars, because the matrix for PAL primaries is at a linear signal point just after the pickup devices and before the gamma correction and encoder. The resulting errors on a black and white receiver were considered too small to worry about compared to those caused by use of gamma-corrected R', G', B' to form Y'.

The above is true for analog signals, and for properly encoded digital NTSC and PAL sources.

When the color bars come from a proper digital HDTV signal (as Y', Cr, Cb), the luminance signals are different from NTSC and PAL because the encoding from RGB to Y, Cr, Cb is adjusted for the relative brightness of the HD primaries.

Yes, it's confusing, and provides employment for those who design hardware and software to convert between the standards and make sure the resulting signals are "legal."
__________________
www.bretl.com
Old TV literature, New York World's Fair, and other miscellany
Reply With Quote
Reply


Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:11 AM.



Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
©Copyright 2012 VideoKarma.org, All rights reserved.