Videokarma.org

Go Back   Videokarma.org TV - Video - Vintage Television & Radio Forums > Early Color Television

Notices

We appreciate your help

in keeping this site going.
Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 04-09-2015, 09:53 AM
etype2's Avatar
etype2 etype2 is offline
VideoKarma Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: Valley of the Sun, formerly Silicon Valley, formerly Packer Land.
Posts: 1,643
Here is a comparison. First photo is from Ed Reitan's CBS field sequential television. Correction: Photography from the screen of John Folsom's 1950 CBS Labs RX-43 CBS Color Receiver as seen on Ed Reitan's website.



Second photo is from a 70 inch 2012 Sharp Quatron LCD.

__________________

Last edited by etype2; 04-09-2015 at 11:37 AM.
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 04-09-2015, 12:56 PM
Electronic M's Avatar
Electronic M Electronic M is offline
M is for Memory
 
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: Pewaukee/Delafield Wi
Posts: 15,496
Quote:
Originally Posted by etype2 View Post
Here is a comparison. First photo is from Ed Reitan's CBS field sequential television. Correction: Photography from the screen of John Folsom's 1950 CBS Labs RX-43 CBS Color Receiver as seen on Ed Reitan's website.

Second photo is from a 70 inch 2012 Sharp Quatron LCD.
There are several different video releases of the Wizard of Oz (it's been discussed on VK before) , and there are wild chroma and general picture quality differences between them. The TBS banner at the bottom of that one shot makes me think those two photos were NOT taken from the same video source.

If you took that flatscreen screen shot, and ED did not take his from the same broadcast, then you are likely comparing apples to oranges, rather than apples to apples.
__________________
Tom C.

Zenith: The quality stays in EVEN after the name falls off!
What I want. --> http://www.videokarma.org/showpost.p...62&postcount=4

Last edited by Electronic M; 04-09-2015 at 01:05 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 04-09-2015, 02:55 PM
etype2's Avatar
etype2 etype2 is offline
VideoKarma Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: Valley of the Sun, formerly Silicon Valley, formerly Packer Land.
Posts: 1,643
Quote:
Originally Posted by Electronic M View Post
There are several different video releases of the Wizard of Oz (it's been discussed on VK before) , and there are wild chroma and general picture quality differences between them. The TBS banner at the bottom of that one shot makes me think those two photos were NOT taken from the same video source.

If you took that flatscreen screen shot, and ED did not take his from the same broadcast, then you are likely comparing apples to oranges, rather than apples to apples.
Yes. If you re-read my post, I explained where the two images came from.

The author of this thread said this in part "I have always sort of liked having a working "roundie" color set around for decades now, but i'm not sure why really. I personally think that they can make as decent a picture as most anything else I have seen, but I also think that the flat screens everyone has gone nuts over don't look that great really. Or not great enough for me to spend the money that they at least once commanded at retail."

I disagree that flat panels don't look great, that is why I posted the roundie screenshot and my screenshot.

I would love to see comparison screenshots of the same exact frame from owners of the CT-100 or any other roundie posted here. My screenshot is from a Direct TV satellite transmission. I suspect other screenshots will look better or worse then my shot, depending on the source.

BTW, I like roundies, too. :-)
__________________
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 04-09-2015, 03:05 PM
DaveWM DaveWM is offline
VideoKarma Member
 
Join Date: Feb 2009
Location: Orlando FL
Posts: 5,607
I don't go around check flat screens often, but IIRC there was something about fast movement that did not look right to me. Maybe that is not the case anymore, but like I said I cant remember the last time I looked at one long enough to know if it was still the same.
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 04-09-2015, 03:18 PM
etype2's Avatar
etype2 etype2 is offline
VideoKarma Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: Valley of the Sun, formerly Silicon Valley, formerly Packer Land.
Posts: 1,643
Quote:
Originally Posted by DaveWM View Post
I don't go around check flat screens often, but IIRC there was something about fast movement that did not look right to me. Maybe that is not the case anymore, but like I said I cant remember the last time I looked at one long enough to know if it was still the same.
Your right. LCD panels have suffered from slow response time and viewing angles. Most of the early problems have been overcome in the newest, better quality panels, but to some degree those problems still persist.

I'm thinking about image quality, ie, color rendition and resolution as compared to the old roundies. Don't get me wrong, I have already said that I'm a fan of roundies. I have two so far and looking for a few more.
__________________
Reply With Quote
Audiokarma
  #6  
Old 04-09-2015, 03:14 PM
dtvmcdonald's Avatar
dtvmcdonald dtvmcdonald is offline
VideoKarma Member
 
Join Date: Nov 2012
Posts: 1,268
The best comparison is the one I did between an original on my computer
screen (i.e. no TV in between) and my CT-100:

http://www.videokarma.org/showthread...=262176&page=6

This is not a screen shot of the computer. Its the original. The
camera image of the CT-100 was tweeked in Photoshop with
the computer monitor sitting om the CT-100 until the images
on the CT-100 and the computer were identical except for brightness.

This is a test of TV resolution, color, and contrast. What you see
on YOUR computer is an accurate report on the DIFFERENCE between
the original as seen on the computer and the image on the TV.
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 04-09-2015, 04:21 PM
etype2's Avatar
etype2 etype2 is offline
VideoKarma Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: Valley of the Sun, formerly Silicon Valley, formerly Packer Land.
Posts: 1,643
Quote:
Originally Posted by dtvmcdonald View Post
The best comparison is the one I did between an original on my computer
screen (i.e. no TV in between) and my CT-100:

http://www.videokarma.org/showthread...=262176&page=6

This is not a screen shot of the computer. Its the original. The
camera image of the CT-100 was tweeked in Photoshop with
the computer monitor sitting om the CT-100 until the images
on the CT-100 and the computer were identical except for brightness.

This is a test of TV resolution, color, and contrast. What you see
on YOUR computer is an accurate report on the DIFFERENCE between
the original as seen on the computer and the image on the TV.
I looked at the three sets of two images on that thread. If I understand correctly, the photos on the left are from the CT-100 and the clearer photos on the right are from the Sony LCD? Or am I wrong?

As to the screen shot I posted, if anyone has the DVD of the Wizard of Oz, the frame is at the 43 minute mark, just before Dorothy meets the scarecrow. You could take a screenshot on your roundie and post it here for comparison purposes.
__________________
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old 04-09-2015, 07:13 PM
dtvmcdonald's Avatar
dtvmcdonald dtvmcdonald is offline
VideoKarma Member
 
Join Date: Nov 2012
Posts: 1,268
Quote:
Originally Posted by etype2 View Post
I looked at the three sets of two images on that thread. If I understand correctly, the photos on the left are from the CT-100 and the clearer photos on the right are from the Sony LCD? Or am I wrong?
.
You are wrong.
The clearer photos are photos made with a Canon 7D camera. They
have not been through video. The comparison is beween the original
and images of the CT100. As I said, the CT100s are adjusted so that
when I am looking at the photos of the CT100 on the same Dell monitor,
the images on the monitor look exactly like the CT100. Thus,
the comparison on YOUR computer is also exactly the same difference
between the original and the CT100.

I post images of the same Dorothy scene. These are made with the same camera. This is a dvd, not a Blu-ray. It is output as NTSC and
modulated on a B-T agile modulator. Both sets look at NTSC
true VSB, cut off at 4.2 MHz an -1.25 MHz.

The sharp one is my Sony Bravia 45 inch LCD and the other two
are the CT100. The camera and processing was set for
no sharpening, no noise reduction, no contrast enhancement,
and 5250K. The camera was defocused to smear out the dot structure.
They were 1/6 second exposures, the f-number was set to compensate for
brightness difference. One CT100 image was changed
in one way: the color temp slider in Photoshop was moved to 4850K.
This makes it look bluer. This is probably a better representation of a by eye comparison; apparently the camera, set for non-auto color temp, is being fooled by phosphor differences.

http://www.videokarma.org/attachment...1&d=1428624485

http://www.videokarma.org/attachment...1&d=1428624485

http://www.videokarma.org/attachment...1&d=1428624485
Attached Images
File Type: jpg DorothyBravia.jpg (64.9 KB, 34 views)
File Type: jpg DorothyCT100.jpg (86.3 KB, 31 views)
File Type: jpg DorothyCT100_4850K.jpg (83.7 KB, 32 views)
Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old 04-09-2015, 08:33 PM
DaveWM DaveWM is offline
VideoKarma Member
 
Join Date: Feb 2009
Location: Orlando FL
Posts: 5,607
http://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j...90491159,d.b2w

I have some pretty good shots from the oz on this video
Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old 04-10-2015, 02:20 AM
etype2's Avatar
etype2 etype2 is offline
VideoKarma Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: Valley of the Sun, formerly Silicon Valley, formerly Packer Land.
Posts: 1,643
Quote:
Originally Posted by dtvmcdonald View Post
You are wrong.
The clearer photos are photos made with a Canon 7D camera. They
have not been through video. The comparison is beween the original
and images of the CT100. As I said, the CT100s are adjusted so that
when I am looking at the photos of the CT100 on the same Dell monitor,
the images on the monitor look exactly like the CT100. Thus,
the comparison on YOUR computer is also exactly the same difference
between the original and the CT100.

I post images of the same Dorothy scene. These are made with the same camera. This is a dvd, not a Blu-ray. It is output as NTSC and
modulated on a B-T agile modulator. Both sets look at NTSC
true VSB, cut off at 4.2 MHz an -1.25 MHz.

The sharp one is my Sony Bravia 45 inch LCD and the other two
are the CT100. The camera and processing was set for
no sharpening, no noise reduction, no contrast enhancement,
and 5250K. The camera was defocused to smear out the dot structure.
They were 1/6 second exposures, the f-number was set to compensate for
brightness difference. One CT100 image was changed
in one way: the color temp slider in Photoshop was moved to 4850K.
This makes it look bluer. This is probably a better representation of a by eye comparison; apparently the camera, set for non-auto color temp, is being fooled by phosphor differences.

http://www.videokarma.org/attachment...1&d=1428624485

http://www.videokarma.org/attachment...1&d=1428624485

http://www.videokarma.org/attachment...1&d=1428624485
To give you my perspective, I am viewing your images on an iPad Air with 2048x1536 resolution, 108% sRGB/Rec.709 color gamut, just slightly blue white at 7041 K. (6500K the standard)

Comments: Image on left looks too blue, looks like 9500 to 11000 K. I see image processing going on in the background.

Image in the center looks the most satisfying, well saturated, but slightly warm.

Image on the right looks like you added a blue filter.

Why did you not set the camera to auto exposure and why did you defocus? I think you would have a truer representation of the images. Yes, the pixel structure would be noticeable on the CRT. Don't we want to see the brightness differences?

May I ask the age of the Sony and was it calibrated to Rec.709? Was your CT-100 calibrated?

Thank you for posting the images, very nice set and images.
__________________

Last edited by etype2; 04-10-2015 at 03:21 AM.
Reply With Quote
Audiokarma
  #11  
Old 04-09-2015, 04:17 PM
Electronic M's Avatar
Electronic M Electronic M is offline
M is for Memory
 
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: Pewaukee/Delafield Wi
Posts: 15,496
Quote:
Originally Posted by etype2 View Post
Yes. If you re-read my post, I explained where the two images came from.

The author of this thread said this in part "I have always sort of liked having a working "roundie" color set around for decades now, but i'm not sure why really. I personally think that they can make as decent a picture as most anything else I have seen, but I also think that the flat screens everyone has gone nuts over don't look that great really. Or not great enough for me to spend the money that they at least once commanded at retail."

I disagree that flat panels don't look great, that is why I posted the roundie screenshot and my screenshot.

I would love to see comparison screenshots of the same exact frame from owners of the CT-100 or any other roundie posted here. My screenshot is from a Direct TV satellite transmission. I suspect other screenshots will look better or worse then my shot, depending on the source.
I just noticed another thing wrong in your comparison the 'roundy' picture is a field sequential set. Field sequential sets are scarce as hens teeth, and are a completely different (and less adjustable) process of color image generation (monochrome CRT with a color wheel spinning in in front of it) than a normal color CRT, and I'd dare say fall outside the most peoples definition of a roundy color set.

I wish I had time to re-read everything, but I don't.

I personally strongly dislike flatscreen sets. Non-Gaussian image elements don't look right to me (a certain softness and cross fade from picture element to picture element makes an image look better), I don't like (makes my eyes tired) the flashing nature of image refresh in a flat screen (versus the soft fade of a CRT), and don't get me started on viewing angle limitations of flat screens and all the maladies digital video has built in to it. If I ever go HD I'm getting an HD CRT set.
__________________
Tom C.

Zenith: The quality stays in EVEN after the name falls off!
What I want. --> http://www.videokarma.org/showpost.p...62&postcount=4
Reply With Quote
  #12  
Old 04-09-2015, 04:40 PM
etype2's Avatar
etype2 etype2 is offline
VideoKarma Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: Valley of the Sun, formerly Silicon Valley, formerly Packer Land.
Posts: 1,643
Quote:
Originally Posted by Electronic M View Post
I just noticed another thing wrong in your comparison the 'roundy' picture is a field sequential set. Field sequential sets are scarce as hens teeth, and are a completely different (and less adjustable) process of color image generation (monochrome CRT with a color wheel spinning in in front of it) than a normal color CRT, and I'd dare say fall outside the most peoples definition of a roundy color set.

I wish I had time to re-read everything, but I don't.

I personally strongly dislike flatscreen sets. Non-Gaussian image elements don't look right to me (a certain softness and cross fade from picture element to picture element makes an image look better), I don't like (makes my eyes tired) the flashing nature of image refresh in a flat screen (versus the soft fade of a CRT), and don't get me started on viewing angle limitations of flat screens and all the maladies digital video has built in to it. If I ever go HD I'm getting an HD CRT set.
You are not telling me anything I don't know. I already said it was a field sequential set and that a better comparison would be to compare a CT-100 or other "modern" roundie from the 60's and sorry, if you don't read through my posts, then I have to respond.

Good luck with your future HD CRT.
__________________
Reply With Quote
  #13  
Old 04-10-2015, 03:36 PM
old_tv_nut's Avatar
old_tv_nut old_tv_nut is offline
See yourself on Color TV!
 
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: Rancho Sahuarita
Posts: 7,815
Quote:
Originally Posted by Electronic M View Post
... I don't like (makes my eyes tired) the flashing nature of image refresh in a flat screen (versus the soft fade of a CRT),
I'm afraid you have it backwards. Flat screen sets (particularly LCDs) display each image continuously; CRTs flash due to the persistence of the phosphor being (sort of) exponential. (Actually, phosphors typically have a main decay that is very rapid compared to field scan rate, but also have an extended low-level tail-off that can produce visible smear of bright objects against a black background; but the major effect by far is the fast drop-off.) Hence, in 50 Hz countries, flicker was always visible on CRTs, not so on LCDs. This characteristic of LCDs also caused smeared motion, alleviated in recent models by going to 120 Hz or 240 Hz refresh rates.
Plasma TVs and micromirror devices get their gray scale by duty cycle modulation, which can cause some artifacts when there is motion present or when the eyeball scans across the image quickly.
__________________
www.bretl.com
Old TV literature, New York World's Fair, and other miscellany
Reply With Quote
Reply


Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:55 PM.



Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
©Copyright 2012 VideoKarma.org, All rights reserved.