Videokarma.org

Go Back   Videokarma.org TV - Video - Vintage Television & Radio Forums > Movies, shows, & programs

Notices

We appreciate your help

in keeping this site going.
Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 06-26-2009, 02:15 PM
mech986's Avatar
mech986 mech986 is offline
LS3/5a Expert, JBL Nut!
 
Join Date: May 2003
Location: La Habra, California, USA
Posts: 25
Quote:
Originally Posted by ducati_EL34 View Post
Forget the plot of the pilot episode, most have. However the story line change was this; according to the pilot episode earth fought a nuclear war. This was not the case of the TOS history. Earth fought a Eugenics war (Space Seed), but, not a planet wide nuclear war.

Spock in Omega Glory says to Kirk, "this planet fought the nuclear war that your planet avoided."

First Contact reinforces this change by Riker stating that 250,000,000 people died in Earth's nuclear war.


Yes TNG was better after Roddenberry let go of the show. Well that and after Will Wheaton was jettisoned from the cast.

Please review "The Omega Glory" again. The actual quotes are:

Kirk: "Yangs...Yanks...Yankees!

Spock: "Komhs....Communists? The parallel is almost too close, Captain. It would mean they fought the war your Earth avoided. In this case, the Asiatics won and took over this planet"
- Transcibed from the Episode I just watched

There is no specific mention of nuclear war here, on Omega IV or on Earth. The references for Earth, in the context of 1960's world views, may be interpreted (my emphasis), as the Cold War and the escalation of that war into armed conflict between the West and Communism. If we avoided that war as stated, it can be interpreted that, at least between the West and Communism in the later mid to late 20th Century, no major armed conflict erupted (Roddenberry's hope for the "future").

McCoy's mention in this same episode about Biological Warfare in the 1990's has an eerie prescience (Anthrax scares, possible vectors like SARS, Botulism, Ebola, even HIV and the like), suggesting that conflicts continued to happen.

The Eugenics Wars erupted along ideological issues with genetic manipulation and genetic engineering, again beginning in the 1990's (again prescient in regards to DNA technology, cloning, Human Genome mapping, etc. in the 90's and this decade). Some 30 million people died in this "war" although it was not clear how they were destroyed. The Memory Alpha page refers to "bombed" out of existence.

http://memory-alpha.org/en/wiki/Eugenics_Wars

There is no mention of East vs. West, Yanks-Comm's in this context. Indeed, the Eugenics Wars were fleshed out in later series as Augmented genetically ("Superior") vs. non-augmented. The war was documented as occurring in though the mid to late 1990's, possibly lasting in to the 2000's.


The Nuclear Wars occurred as an aftermath of the Eugenics Wars, when a multitude of conflicts arose and many world governments were destroyed. Parts of those conflicts included "Eco-Terrorists" like Colonel Green (From TOS: The Savage Curtain, referred to by Spock in TOS: Bread and Circuses, and ENT: In A Mirror Darkly, Part II) whose inital attacks in 2026 was acknowledged as the beginning of WW III. This set the stage for Nuclear War to whomever had access to the weapons (not seemingly from country governments but more from terrorists, tyrants and military commanders who gained access to all the stockpiled weapons of the 20th century - sounds frighteningly familiar to today??).

The Radiation sickened populace that Colonel Green exterminated strongly suggests nuclear war, or at least "dirty bomb" type technology.
http://memory-alpha.org/en/wiki/Phillip_Green

Yes, the subsequent events of WW III from 2026 to 2053 are mostly fleshed out in later Star Trek vehicles like ST:First Contact, ST:TNG, and ST:ENT. But much of the foundations or story "sparks" come from statements first used in ST:TOS. Subsequent writers and producers have tried to envision the "future" through filling in the "history", thus giving more substance and storyline to the show.

http://memory-alpha.org/en/wiki/World_War_III

I think most writers, including Braga, and Berman, and others, did a good job balancing writing entertainment with staying reasonably true to the "future history" that TOS first established or suggested, and then they fleshed them out. We (collectively the fans) might have wanted to do it differently, but that's what they (writers, produceres, and, yes, the studio) decided to put out and generally accepted as "canon".

As for Roddenberry, well, it was his vision that established the tenets of Star Trek, and when he wrote or outlined the pilot, that was in the midst of the Reagan ERA with the Cold War escalating further. It was not a hard stretch to again outline how humanity would have sank deeper into oblivion (Nuclear War, narcotic controlled soldiers, genocidal wars - much of this is happening now or may happen - frightening isn't it, so his vision is not far off). He used Q to bring all of humanity's failures into focus, and re-establish the Star Trek theme that Humanity eventually conquered that and evolved for the better.

One other thing. "Brannon and Braga". His name is Brannon Braga, and he was writing a lot with Rick Berman. I suspect you are referring to Berman and Braga in regards to the writing?

BTW, Brannon Braga, since starting in 1993 on TNG as a story editor, worked his way up into head writer, producer and Exec. Producer for Star Trek series and movies. Of course, not everything he's done is critically acclaimed but much of it is interesting and does reflect a solid knowledge and understanding of the ST universe. He has since gone on to do great work on the series 24.

http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0103804/

EDIT: so essentially, even though there was not a specific mention of nuclear war in TOS's future, it did not specifically exclude it.

Regards,

Bart, EMH
__________________
Karma - what goes around, comes around!!
AudioKarma - The Best Forum on the Web!!

Last edited by mech986; 06-26-2009 at 02:23 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 06-26-2009, 03:31 PM
ducati_EL34's Avatar
ducati_EL34 ducati_EL34 is offline
AK Member
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Posts: 127
Quote:
Originally Posted by mech986 View Post

EDIT: so essentially, even though there was not a specific mention of nuclear war in TOS's future, it did not specifically exclude it.

Regards,

Bart, EMH
Thanks for filling in some of the gaps. I still have a problem with their version of trek history.

In Space Seed, kirk says to spock, something along the lines of, "i wonder why there is no mention of this flight (DY-100) in the history tapes?" Spock replies, "Captain, would you let a war weary population know that 30 of their supermen are missing?"

Now if there was a full scale nuke war with a side order of Eugenics and Bio warfare, and for dessert they will be having a total collapse of governments, oh and the check comes to 250,000,000 dead, do you think spock would have used the phrase "war weary"? I don't.

Oh and if did happen as the TNG episode says, do you think the remnants of civilization would care about 30 supermen blasting off into space? I think the answer is, "no".

Then there are a couple of other episodes, where they go back in time, circa 1969, and no mention amoung themselves about this upcoming devestation? In fact why was there never any mention of this planet wide nuke war in TOS? Something like that is bound to have come up at some point. you don't forget something like that. We have people today, who still debate the cause of the The Great War, and that pales in comparison...

Now on to the TNG pilot episode. If as you say Roddenberry is writing the pilot with the Reagan era and nuclear buildup in mind. Too bad! Roddenberry has already written his trek history in TOS. He can not change it, just to suit his political whims.

I do not have a problem with a tactical nukes being used. In fact I never ruled that out in the first place.

I am not referencing anything from Enterprise, Voyager, or DS9. That would be revisionist history, if Farpoint is indeed a blunder. I am speaking strictly from a TOS reference.

Then there is the Warp capable Phoenix in First Contact. How was he suppose to return to earth, once he made the maiden voyage. Seems to me, he is asking a lot of an converted ICBM...
__________________
“I feel sorry for people who don't drink. When they wake up in the morning, that's as good as they're going to feel all day.” -- Frank Sinatra

Last edited by ducati_EL34; 06-26-2009 at 03:46 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 06-26-2009, 07:14 PM
ec1st ec1st is offline
AK Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: S.C. Pennsylvania
Posts: 6
Ok, make it better.

Here's where the fun really starts. It's easy to criticize from the home recliner when a writer puts a little spin into a story that interrupts one's suspension of disbelief. So consider this: just how easy is it to create a workable and interesting Trek story?

A show of virtual hands, please... How many have ever tried to write a piece of Trek fan fiction?
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 06-26-2009, 08:10 PM
ducati_EL34's Avatar
ducati_EL34 ducati_EL34 is offline
AK Member
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Posts: 127
Quote:
Originally Posted by ec1st View Post
Here's where the fun really starts. It's easy to criticize from the home recliner when a writer puts a little spin into a story that interrupts one's suspension of disbelief. So consider this: just how easy is it to create a workable and interesting Trek story?

A show of virtual hands, please... How many have ever tried to write a piece of Trek fan fiction?
Sure, writing a story that has a compelling plot is hard. Well except for people like Jane Austin, Charles Dickens, et al...

I am not a writer, however, these people are writers. They should get to know the history of the show, and write in accordance with that history.
__________________
“I feel sorry for people who don't drink. When they wake up in the morning, that's as good as they're going to feel all day.” -- Frank Sinatra
Reply With Quote
Reply


Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:52 PM.



Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
©Copyright 2012 VideoKarma.org, All rights reserved.