Quote:
Originally Posted by Carmine
The discrimination in this case is against those of us who like to imagine we live in a free-market economy where broadcasters and consumers would decide when we "go digital", not lobbyists representing an industry that needs a big seller to keep the assembly lines running in the Shang-Dong province of a communist nation.
We (taxpayers) are already subsidizing the cost of this switch via the $40 set-top coupons... Or were you expecting to see your federal taxes reduced because the government is about to have a windfall for the analog spectrum?  Then we'll subsidize the clean-up and/or recycling of millions of TV sets obsoleted overnight by government decree.
But I digress...
Since I've already accepted/expected greed and corruption as a system of government years ago; it would be nice if all-knowing big-brother would allow at least some portion (1-2 channels worth) of the vacated spectrum TV to remain for local public/non-profit/emergency usage. I would think boss-man would allow us at least this symbolic table-scrap. 
|
OK, what I would do is, if I was king, the VHF channels (2 - 13) and UHF channels 14 thru 50 would still be NTSC and 51 thru 83 would be HDTV (ATSC). If I understand correctly, the old AMPS phone standard for cellphones was supposed to stop in 2007 thus freeing channels 70 thru 83 again. If AMPS is still around, then make the allocations 14 - 45 NTSC and 46 - 69 HDTV then. That way, let the free market decide. Then if HDTV takes off, I would then use all the UHF channel for it and then I would still leave NTSC on the VHF channels, I mean it would be nice for emergencies, otherwise HDTV would be useless and AM radio would be our only source of news and the like.
I think it is wrong to sell off the spectrum, it is a limited resource and there is not a lot of it so keeping it in the public interest would be the wisest thing to do. Unfortunatly ever since the Reagan era, we have put up a lot of things that should still be publically held up for sale. I understand doing this with some public lands, there is a whole buttload of land other there that can be utilized better but when it comes to the radio spectrum, a very limited resource, it is dead wrong. Sorry for getting a little political there but IMHO, there are very few on them who really work for the public interests, most have sold out to their "Big Governess" (a coalition of Big Business and Big Government) lobbyists.