I thought the first Alien film was the best of the series ... but then again, I saw it in a theater when it first came out, not knowing what to expect. I saw it with some friends, and we sort of guessed it would be an updated spoof of the 50s horror flicks. With that expectation, and nothing remotely like it ever having been released before, the film blew us out of our seats - sometimes literally, with surprise/shock!
Anyone seeing it later, or today, after so many imitations and variations/derivatives have been made. and with modern CGI making everything possible visually, will never recapture that impact/effect. The second movie, Aliens, already suffered likewise from 'familiarity syndrome' -- it was good, but one already knew too much what to expect, knew the formula, so to speak, so it just wasn't as enjoyable. Yes, they had a bigger budget for the second one, so technically it is better-made - but it wasn't as good when I saw it first, for the reason I've just explained; there wasn't as much suspense and shock involved.
Only a few movies in my life were "quantum leap" films -- that is, films that "blew me away" by how good they were for the time that they were released, or how different/creative they were. Star Wars and Alien are at the top of that list, Predator a close second. I doubt I will ever see another movie with remotely the same impact, now that CGI has made "anything" possible on a screen. Perhaps if they perfect 3-D "holographic immersion" movies that surround the moviegoer with a realistic filmscape, of maybe if the talkies we now enjoy are superseded by "feelies", then I'll enjoy that kind of impact again. [Oooh, porno flicks in feelie-vision! Or murder movies - ouch!

} Otherwise, every movie is now "just another movie" to me, even if it might be "a good one".