![]() |
|
|
|
#1
|
||||
|
||||
|
Another reason I hate HDTV...
I don't get the hype regarding picture quality, although I can only judge by what I've seen in stores. Only when the screen size gets "huge" can I really notice the difference between HDTV and a good quality conventional set. The expensive sets display a nice picture, but since my living room isn't 40' wide like the showroom, I don't need a 50" picture.
However my complaint is not about picture quality, but rather this new 16:9 aspect ratio. Except for some sporting events, and epic films like Ben Hur, is 16:9 really the best way to frame a shot? Most TV shots are of a single person speaking, fairly close. Yet by the time you get back far enough to frame the complete head/bust in the shot, you've included a bunch of unnessecary junk (like the fence in the head shot of yours truly). Even inanimate objects like cars, houses, etc. are usually closer to square than "super wide", so you must include a bunch of extra stuff (such as the the SUV turning left in the first shot of the Rolls Royce). You end up with a smaller shot of the subject, no matter what. Perhaps not a problem on a 50" screen, but what about portable/table sets of the future? Does anybody else think this is stupid?
__________________
From Captain Video, 1/4/2007 "It seems that Italian people are very prone to preserve antique stuff." |
|
#2
|
||||
|
||||
|
With HDTV you need a down-conversion box for a regular TV and they are expensive now (like the up-convertors for SDTV to HDTV). You need to have the proper scaler in line among other things. As soon as the HDTV std really shakes out - change will happen really fast!!
dave
__________________
"Resentment is like taking poison yourself and waiting for the other guy to die." -Carrie Fisher |
|
#3
|
||||
|
||||
|
I think the 16:9 or similar widescreen ratios were orginally developed around 1953 for movies in theaters, to give a wider field of view and to fill up the stage area...it was developed in large part to give movies an extra distinction over the new competetion at that time of television.
In my opinion, like Carmine I think this wide screen ratio is only valuable when there is actually stuff to SEE in that expanded area that matters in terms of the story...for TV and a lot of what is in movies I just think it is not really needed. Much of the time I have seen a 4:3 image stretched sideways to fit into a 16:9 screen. Maybe there will be 4:3 ratio digital TV's available that give you the ability to crop off the sides of the 16:9 image. |
|
#4
|
||||
|
||||
|
Quote:
__________________
From Captain Video, 1/4/2007 "It seems that Italian people are very prone to preserve antique stuff." |
|
#5
|
||||
|
||||
|
I expect to enter the HD market soon myself, and I've looked at a number of sets, both in stores and in rooms (bars, restaurants, homes, etc.).
I agree that we aught to go back to the 4:3 ratio. As Chad mentioned, Cinematic style has changed from the epic "Ben Hurr" days, so that 4:3 seems more beneficial even for movies. Also, horizontal space (the TV's "footprint") is much more expensive in a home than the vertical space. I hate the prospect of needing more than twice the width to get close to the same screen size. Also, unless I get a HUGE HT screen that takes up most of my wall (which will be purchased through future lottery winnings), the picture really seems squashed to me. Maybe that's just because I'm so used to the 4:3 ratio, but everybody'sl in that situation. 16:9 is just there to match a standard that's somewhat obsolete, IMO. However, I DO really like the higher resolution. One of my pet peaves is being too close to a medium-to-large TV, so that the horizontal lines are too obvious. My perception goes from "I'm observing a story" to "I'm watching a television image". I've noticed that I can get as close as I want to an HD set of any size without seeing those lines. However, for smaller sets, a standard def. flat panel makes more sense to me. |
| Audiokarma |
|
#6
|
||||
|
||||
|
I'm not an industry slappy, but I do support the 16:9 ratio for this and this reason only; it's the way the film was originally shot and crafted by the director. To view it any other way is a compromise of what the director wanted to show. Granted, there's more of an effect with LOTR or Lawrence of Arabia than the latest Jack Black flic, but I usually only buy DVDs of that nature.
BTW, I don't have a big screen, 27" is the big screen here. but I do buy all my DVDs as widescreen, because that's what you see in the theatre. There is also an option that stretches out non 16:9 programming to 16:9. I can't believe that any manufacturer would use it, but I've seen it on a Philips we sell at Costco. The kids playing football look like a bunch of little fat blobs running about
__________________
I think the world is run by "C" students - Al McGuire |
|
#7
|
||||
|
||||
|
Quote:
If you have a 50" 16:9 screen and are watching a 4:3 program it will basically be like watching a 40" 4:3 set which ain't too bad. ![]() I recently made the jump to HDTV and I'm loving it, even though I've never actually watched any true HD programs on it, mostly DVD's which aren't really HD but look spectacular anyway.
Last edited by Eric H; 02-02-2005 at 10:20 PM. |
|
#8
|
||||
|
||||
|
Quote:
I have recently got Direct TV (no cable available in my area) and have not watched antenna TV for months! Have been using the digital recorder to record my favorite shows and that is more than I can usually watch in a day. I know that HD is available on Direct TV but think that they would keep compatibility with their current receivers, as the signal coming into the satellite dish is digital anyway. Even though there are some digital artifacts sometimes noticeable, the picture quality is MUCH better than what I was getting with antenna and of course the programming is a lot better. My parents got an HDTV 16:9 set but when I went to visit them and watched it, did not think the improvement in the picture was good enough to me to want to buy a new set...am still using my 60's and 70's sets. Last edited by Chad Hauris; 02-03-2005 at 07:23 AM. |
|
#9
|
|||
|
|||
|
We had digital cable here for a while, and dropped it after two months. It wasn't HD, but the picture was just SO BAD that it wasn't worth the trouble for the extra channels. The analog picture has always been crystal clear, and only fuzzy on a couple channels. The digital picture was always full of digital artifacts, it would skip frames/get stuck frequently, and the sound sometimes dropped out. The cable company could never get it to work properly. They swapped out the receiver box a couple of times, and for a while we had a DVR. All the digital boxes suffered from the same major pain in the neck problem - the delay when changing channels. I don't know about the rest of you, but when I press the "Channel UP" button on my remote, I expect the channel to flip to the next highest number. Instantly (or pretty close to it). Not in two seconds, not in one second, and reliably every time. This thing was horrible, the delay between any action on the remote and the actual action was very annoying. Not only that, but the digital box didn't even have a display! Sure, it had a clock, but is it too much to ask to have a couple little numbers on the front of the box that tell the number of the current channel? I mean, this isn't compicated stuff here.
Another pet peeve - DVR's. The one we got from the cable company was a piece of total junk. Sure, you could set it to record shows. But then what? It's stuck in that box. Not only that, but the quality was absolutely terrible. It was like watching a VHS tape that was recorded at the SLP speed, on very, very low quality, worn tape. The picture was just that bad. The digital artifacts only got worse on the recording, and the colors were all faded and 'compressed' looking (you know, that grain from bad image compression). Also, you'd see things where not the entire screen was being updated, so you'd get this smear across the screen as a character moved or something. Sure, it varied, but it was generally always pretty bad. Sound was flat sounding too. Also, say, for instance, you now wanted to copy ths show you had recorded. Simple, huh? I mean, it's a digital format, so I should just be able to connect the firewire port on the back of the box to my computer, and transfer... wrong! Those ports aren't even active. It says so deep in the manual. (And yes, I tried it. It didn't work.) Also, if the cable goes out, or the box gets moved and isn't hooked up to the cable, it doesn't work. At all. You can't even play the shows you've recorded to the internal hard drive. Oh... right... the topic... Back to HDTV - from what I've seen of HDTV, the picture is, indeed clearer. But is is necessary? I too absolutely hate the 16:9 aspect ratio. It's totally unweildy and not well suited to much of anything, save for certain wide shots, which the directors can't seem to use right anyway. Right now, on regular television, they can't even come up with programming that's any good on a 4:3 screen. Do they think a wider screen will magically make "Survivor" good? Do they think that new technology will make their bad writing better? I don't know. Do I _need_ to watch these shows in high definition - no, especially since I don't watch them anyway. Now, I do watch TV. I absolutely love CSI, Law and Order, Star Trek, Stargate SG-1, and a lot of other shows. Some of which are available in HD. But I've never found myself thinking. "Gee, I wish CSI was higher resolution", or "Man, 512 lines just isn't enough to convey the true terror of the Klingon battle cruiser". They're even using 16:9 for laptop screens now! Laptops! Isn't the point of a laptop to make it SMALLER? Not only that, but what use is a wide screen on a laptop? Word processor documents are still not going to fit very well, and Windows will still not be bearable even with a longer taskbar. I really wonder how Linux would run on one of those things, I mean, the standard 80x24 console would be rather stretched. Emacs would look really weird. Also, speaking of modern television, has anyone noticed that the cameramen seem to have gotten really terrible as of late? What happened, did they cheap out on tripods, or have they just been serving up stronger coffee at the studio? </rant> Hehe, oops. Sorry 'bout the rambling there... -Ian |
|
#10
|
||||
|
||||
|
You should get an antenna and digital off-air receiver box to go with that 55-inch set - you will definitely see the difference in Hi-Def sports. (We get the Cubs and Bulls local games in HD in Chicago --- OK, maybe that's a bad example...) Joking aside, football games and other sports look fantastic.
Olympics were beautiful, too bad NBC did only a loop of partial coverage. HD movies look good too, but if you want a significant quantity you have to consider HD cable or satellite. Prime-time dramas look great, too, but I don't know how much it really contributes to the story. However, CBS in Washington DC said that if they accidentally send out "The Young and the Restless" in standard def, they get complaints! So there are some appreciative people watching even that in HD. Personal opinion: below 30-inch, its hard for a CRT to have enough resolution to show a big difference in HD. HD LCD's or plasmas are very good at showing the resolution in this size and up, but still expensive. Something like a 55-inch rear projection is about the best bang for the buck right now, but if you just must hang it on the wall, you could wait for prices to come down some more. |
| Audiokarma |
|
#11
|
||||
|
||||
|
I've looked at rear projection sets, and decided I'll wait until I can afford an LCD or plasma. Off-axis viewing fades quite noticeably, and even if you're sitting dead-center, the brightness is focused in the center portion of the screen.
|
|
#12
|
||||
|
||||
|
I'm not up on HDTV, but I keep hearing that HD requires tremendous bandwidth and that most stations will be broadcasting at reduced bandwidth with the end result being only slightly better than what we currently have. Anyone have any comments or knowledge of this?
__________________
Let me live in the house beside the road and be a friend to man. |
|
#13
|
||||
|
||||
|
Our local FOX affiliate (WHBQ 13 Memphis) sucks too...and in so many ways.
__________________
Let me live in the house beside the road and be a friend to man. |
|
#14
|
||||
|
||||
|
All HDTV will be in 16:9 format - that is part of the HD. Just go read the forums at http://www.avsforum.com .
Dave
__________________
"Resentment is like taking poison yourself and waiting for the other guy to die." -Carrie Fisher |
|
#15
|
||||
|
||||
|
Quote:
Marketers probably think only a handful of oddballs (such as myself) would want something like that anyhow. And they're likely correct!
|
| Audiokarma |
![]() |
|
|