Pete,
I finally had to "bite the bullet" when my 36" CRT set went belly up. I spent two days looking at all models and types of HD sets. What I found was that the "projection" type sets, DLP, LCOS, have a "sweet" spot to view for maximum brightness and detail, that to me was very annoying. This is almost exactly the same problem that I see on the 40's projection sets.
I settled on a SONY 46" XBR3 LCD, mainly because no matter where I was standing in the showroom the picture quality was the same, and my eyes where just drawn back to that set, same programming on all sets in show room, also I just couldn't see the difference in the plasma display to warrant the extra cost.
The one thing that I notice, again just my opinion, conventional NTSC programming doesn't have that much impact, but when switched to a local 1080i program everything just seems to jump out at you. Next on my list is a HD DVD player, which way should I go

, I guess toss a coin.
Chuck