Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Whitehall
While there were a couple of cute moments, on the whole, I was embarassed by it. It just couldn't stop from ridiculing Southerners and in the most stupid, banal, stereotypical manner possible.
As a society, we've made it clear that "Negro" jokes, Polish jokes, etc, etc are unsuitable for civil discourse and for good reason. Today, Hollywood thinks that Southerners and the Amish ("Kingpin") are fair game and outside any respect or deserving of dignity we otherwise expect to show everyone else and each other.
|
I think this is sorta missing the idea of the movie. Exaggerating characters has been a part of literature since...well...forever! Just read anything by Mark Twain. When characters are so completely over the top as in O' Brother and Kingpin (or any Mel Brooks movies for that matter), it is impossible to equate that with any type of defamation.
The true targets of ridicule were characters like the Klansmen.
What the Coen Brothers did so magnificiently was take these Depression-era stereotypes and blow them up into bigger-than-life characters with qualities, however outrageous, that the viewer can relate to in one way or another.
I think your claim that Hollywood pulls no punches with mocking Southerners is as untrue as saying Hollywood pulls no punches when mocking Jews or Canadians or Blacks. Yes, there are Comedies that mock/satirize different peoples (South Park Movie as anti-Canada propaganda?), but to say they do that outright without a sense of satire or self-criticism (from the perspective of the writer & viewer) isn't true in my view.
Just my 4 kopeks.