Boytris I have tried reading the book, when I saw the movie it reminded me of why the books always turned me off. Just not my kind of Fantasy, of course I have never liked Piers Anthony or those Greywall books either. Just different strokes for different folks.
Fortunately or unfortunately all swords and sorcery fantasy movies are going to be compared to LOTR, it's now the benchmark. Just as Star Wars is the guage to which sci-fi is judged. So LOTR comparisons are gonna happen.
Even not comparing it to LOTR I would still have found it too kiddie like for me. I am a sucker for movies with swords in them and I just have trouble with movies that have 12yr olds who have never even held a sword vanquishing axe weilding monsters and all the while without any blood flying

It was like medievel fantasy A-Team reruns.
I can see why fans of the book or children (walking, talking beavers anyone????) would enjoy it. But for the average sci fi/fantasy/action junkie it is lacking.