|
I agree that any auto color system is a bad idea if you want the most accurate color possible. The worst system I ever saw was what Sony did in the 70's. They combined the auto color and auto fine tuning into one switch. You couldn't turn on the AFT without the auto color. To make matters worse, these Sony sets usually produced a massively over saturated picture when the auto color was turned on. I actually disabled the auto color on my KV-5100 so I could use the AFT.
VIR was a good idea, but it never caught on and it sounds like it was poorly implemented by the TV stations. The basic idea was that the TV station would broadcast a line with a known signal on it. The TV would then adjust the color and tint until this signal matched what this reference should be. This is better than auto color which just distorted the color decoding so that flesh tones wouldn't look too far off even with the tint misadjusted slightly. VIR assumed that the TV station was handling their color properly and that the hue errors were happening in broadcast, or in the receiver. The problem is that if the TV station's reference is off, your set would misadjust itself. If the TV station was doing its job in the first place, auto color wouldn't be needed. Other than GE, I have seen a few Sony TVs with VIR.
|