|
From your description of it, GE's VIR sounds to me like most other attempts at completely automatic color balance in color TV--it was close to if not in fact a complete flop. I don't know what part of the vertical interval reference signal the VIR system used, but whatever it was and however the system used that signal it must not have done a very good job. GE must have realized this eventually, as VIR disappeared from its TVs a short while after it was introduced. Again, as I mentioned in my last post, the best way to compensate for color variations between programs, scenes or channels, IMO, is to switch off the auto-color button or auto color circuit (if your set has either system) and manually adjust the tint and/or contrast controls until the picture looks right to your eyes. Some sets, such as many late-model Zeniths (and most RCAs made in the last ten years or so, including current production of course), have the contrast control circuitry arranged so that the contrast control actually adjusts the color balance and contrast together; this makes adjusting for pleasing color balance much easier than trying to strike a balance between brightness, contrast and color, as was necessary with older color sets which had no auto color systems.
Last night (and again just before starting to write this today), as I thought about the statement I made in my last post that Zenith did not choose to use auto-color systems in its mid-to-late-1970s vintage color TVs, it occurred to me that the company did in fact incorporate a feature it called Color Sentry in those sets. The company claimed in its ads for Zenith color consoles of 1976-78 that this system adjusted the color, brightness and contrast of the picture 30 times every second. "Think of it as a control room in your set", the ads proclaimed. The feature disappeared from Zenith TVs a few years later and hasn't been seen in any of the company's sets since then--certainly not in any Zenith-branded GoldStar sets I am aware of.
As with GE's VIR system, I don't know exactly how Color Sentry worked, but again, it is entirely possible that the sets produced much better pictures with this feature switched off. In fact, I think it's safe to say that most people who had Zeniths with Color Sentry (or any other brand of TV with an auto-color button) didn't know what the button was for, or even that it was there in the first place. Many non-technical TV viewers, then as now, did not/don't even bother to read the manual; once the set was/is installed, these folks just use the set and never bother with the color controls or anything else other than the on/off switch, channel selector and volume control. These are the folks the various auto-color systems were designed to cater to, but the systems really weren't that good, so they eventually disappeared from most sets. My own 5-year-old RCA "XL-100" has the auto-color control's defeat switch hidden in a multi-layer on-screen menu (the auto-color system is enabled by default). I know it's there, but I'd be willing to bet, if I were a betting man (which I'm not), that most ordinary viewers do not. Today, installing a CRT-based TV set entails little more than unpacking the set from a box, hooking it up to an antenna or cable system, plugging it in and watching it, with little or no regard for (or even awareness of) any on-screen menus which the set may or may not have. (Installation of plasma and LCD sets is much more complicated, but that's another story.) Heck, many people don't even know how to change the batteries in the remote when they go dead! As long as the set works, that's all that matters. I have known people who will watch a color picture in which the colors are completely wrong or even missing; they don't seem to notice the difference, as long as the set produces a picture. Many people will even watch a color TV whose picture is so dim they have to watch it in the dark; this was common in color TV's early days, when color CRTs were very expensive to replace (and the sets themselves were expensive as well; these were the days when TV sets and other appliances were repaired and held onto thereafter for years when they developed problems, not put out for the trash at the first sign of trouble, or even when the CRT goes, even if the set is only a year or two old, as is commonplace nowadays).
The so-called "automatic" systems were intended to take critical picture adjustments for contrast, brightness and hue out of the viewer's hands, but as it turns out, the best color adjustment system still is the manual kind, where the viewer adjusts the controls until the picture looks natural to his or her eyes. The most difficult colors for any color television set to produce are flesh tones; get these right and, supposedly, the rest of the colors will be correct as well. Any automatic color system, no matter how sophisticated, is no substitute for the human eye and personal preferences.
Say what you will about the quality of today's TV sets, but IMO, one of the best things color TV manufacturers ever did was to eliminate those automatic color systems. As I stated in my last post, the quality of your TV picture is only as good as the signal your set receives. The GIGO principle applies here: garbage in, garbage out. Conversely, if your local TV stations and/or cable system deliver a really good signal to your set, so will your TV's picture be excellent--if the TV has been set up properly in the first place. Often the problem is with the cable system, if you have cable; small systems sometimes do a poor job of balancing signal levels, etc. but again, if your TV has been set up properly, it isn't the set's fault. Again, the GIGO principle applies. Regardless how good a TV set is, if it is fed a poor signal, it will display a poor picture. Many people have been disappointed when they try to use a wide-screen TV with rabbit ears. The wide screen will often show up snow, interference, etc. which may have been barely noticeable on the older set the widescreen replaced. This is why most TV technicians will tell widescreen TV owners to use either a good outdoor antenna or cable/satellite as a signal source for their new sets. Standard 4:3 aspect ratio color TV requires a very strong signal to operate properly; this goes at least double for 16:9 widescreen plasma and LCD sets. The larger the screen, the more pronounced any interference or other artifacts in the picture will be.
__________________
Jeff, WB8NHV
Collecting, restoring and enjoying vintage Zenith radios since 2002
Zenith. Gone, but not forgotten.
|