View Single Post
  #39  
Old 12-30-2014, 04:54 AM
Carmine's Avatar
Carmine Carmine is offline
...enjoys spaghetti.
 
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Detroit area
Posts: 1,612
I think what you're not taking into account is that decisions like not switching to printed circuits, or a failure to build tubes larger than 27" do not occur in a vacuum (no pun intended). The dominos which started eating the profit from Zenith's bottom line started falling in the very late 1950s. For at least a decade the effects were small... First they ceded the market on low-profit items like portable radios. But eventually even their high-margin items were under attack. Smaller companies like Admiral simply faded away. Larger parent companies like Motorola sold off their consumer divisions.

Zenith's strategy was to seek remedy in the court system. Often, they would win damages (which might have paid for new capital investment) but what happens when a foreign company simply fails to pay the US government or a US company? A shooting war? Not so much. US trade legislation is largely an executive branch power and that means no one has a career that lasts longer than 8-years (sometimes 4). How many of the FTC or Commerce Department lawyers who had the responsibility of writing/enforcing/collecting trade legislation/duties ended up with a lucrative career at a law firm representing a Japanese manufacturer... Or sometimes directly employed by same? Do you think the real Elliot Ness-style hardasses got those job offers? In at least one case a guy got busted back to processing FOIA requests for being "too agressive".

Meanwhile its very easy to say "well they never got into xyz market", but when capital is limited, what eventually suffers? R&D. Those new areas where they did choose to invest, FTM, HDTV and even laser projection systems ended up as dead ends.

As further proof, Sony was never named in any of these lawsuits or found guilty of any dumping charges. They'd chosen a premium space in the market, not the $199 19" area that was eating the bottom out of a $329 Zenith set. If they faced only Sony at a similar price point, I imagine the outcome would have been different. Perhaps that's the reason Zenith eventually did much business with Sony in areas where they could no longer afford new captial investment.

Consider that it took the Japanese much longer to penetrate Europe (and American companies never did) why do you suppose that was? Perhaps their heavily protected markets vs. our wide open borders? Ya think?

To say that defective CRTs or multiple cabinets finishes killed Zenith is like saying heart failure is the cause of death for a guy with lung cancer. Yes, when the heart stops beating we declare someone dead, but if the heart is damaged after years being deprived of oxygen, do you still blame the heart? If you never consider cause and effect, you'll never cut the number of deaths.
__________________
From Captain Video, 1/4/2007
"It seems that Italian people are very prone to preserve antique stuff."
Reply With Quote