|
The horrors with timecode in the US date back to the introduction of NTSC colour in 1954. To minimise patterning the relationship between the colour subcarrier and sound carrier frequencies was critical. At the time they decided to shift the whole monochorme signal frequency by 0.1% rather than change the sound carrier frequency by the same amount. Saved re-aligning a load of B&W sets that might have suffered from distorted sound. 15 years or so later when timecode arrived there was a horrible mess. Besides the usual dropframe there need to be longer term corrections to stop timecode drifting away from clock time. We're still paying the price.
With all systems there is no such thing as perfection. With the technology of the day there were significant compromises for showing 24fps film on TV. In 60Hz countries this was either judddery 3:2 pulldown or smeary vidicon effects. In 50Hz countries it was 4% fast, sometime with audio pitch corrected. It's now possible to do good quality frame rate conversion 24>25 and 24>30(29.97). I don't know how much film is thus converted for TV.
If you want real comedy look at how silent film was often shown on TV. Typically shot at 16-18fps, it was often shown at 25fps in 50Hz countries. The Keystone Cops sure looked comical when that happened.
Incidentally the reason why sound film was shot at 24fps wasn't for improved appearance of motion. It was to get adequate sound quality on an optical track. 16-18fps was just too slow to get even mediocre quality. It's not as if "Academy" sound at 24fps was particularly good.
|