Oh god I feel like an idiot.
This whole time I'm going through my VCR. I bypass it, and it's nice and bright!!
The VCR thinks this TV is another VCR and is kicking in the macrovision, and causing the picture to darken, and brighten, darken and brighten. I was using the VCR as an AV switch and was getting the same results.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xBg95pphFBY