View Single Post
  #34  
Old 08-14-2011, 04:29 PM
MelodyMaster's Avatar
MelodyMaster MelodyMaster is offline
78s Galore.
 
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Mississauga, Ont, Canada
Posts: 86
Incidentally, (sorry for the multiple posts) because of this conversation I dragged the Ikegami into the living room. Now, this is a 1968 all-solid state Ikegami that used to be a camera control monitor at CBC. It has an original Conrac picture tube with broadcast phosphors, A VERY expensive tube once..I put it on the composite output of the Bell (satellite) PVR, and watched portions of Torchwood, some movies, MSNHD, a few other things on the box, and the colour is IDENTICAL between the Ikegami and Samsung plasma. The greens, cyans, blues and yellows are spot on, dark tinted greys are extrememly close, flesh tones are identical, the Ikegami gives SLIGHTLY more red to skin blush areas, but only when comparing side by side. This Samsung is as good a broadcast check monitor as the Ikegami. That's interesting actually because the Ikegami is supposed to be set to Rec 601, whereas the Samsung is Rec 709, which depends upon less saturated red phosphors and has a slightly narrower gamut than 601. Nevertheless, there you have it, the best CRT monitor in the business is NOT providing a richer, more accurate picture than a modern, cheap, Plasma. I wish I could take an accurate picture. I'll work on that.

And remember that in the brightness race NO consumer colour TV made since 1957 actually HAS a tube with accurate NTSC broadcast phophors. Any CRT set you choose will do much worse than this broadcast Ikegami. Skin tones will be pale - more pinkish, greens will be bluish, blues desaturated, and greys green-tinted.

Which doesn't change the opinion I always had, that the pictures on that Ikegami are just gorgeous - but it doesn't offer HD.
Reply With Quote