View Single Post
  #5  
Old 03-29-2011, 08:31 PM
charokeeroad's Avatar
charokeeroad charokeeroad is offline
John Q
 
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: Southern California, IE
Posts: 644
Quote:
Originally Posted by pugs5061 View Post
I am restoring the same set and I have been scrubbing and waxing and scrubbing and waxing for what seems like forever. The bakelight is just plain faded like yours. Yours looks great and I am probably going to end up staining mine after seeing your results. Two questions for you though. Not being able to see it in person how close a match do you think you had with the red oak? Would something with a little more brown be in order if I wanted stay closer to the bakelight color? Secondly, I'm thinking I'd want to try for a higher gloss finish. If I used a high gloss Poly to achieve this, I'd like to here your comments.
Thanx,
Bret
Pugs5061. I know what your talking about. No matter how hard or long you scrub and wax you can't get the Bakelite color back. I used Red Oak for a first coat and that's the color you see on the pics that were taken outside. Like you I wanted to get it a little darker so I went back over it with Colonial Cherry . I think you could also try Red Mahogany. The finished pics show a color more like Bakelite.

The staining part is about as easy as it gets. Just dip a cloth or paper towel into the stain and go to work. I didn't let any stain build up and the cabinet just seemed to take as much stain as it needed to give it color uniformity. I used stain without poly included. I was shocked at how good it looks with just the stain. I did wipe it until it got smooth and a bit of a shine developed. I was tempted to leave it like that but I also wanted to see what a poly finish would look like so I pushed on.

The poly finish was a little more tricky. I first shot water based poly and I wasn't really happy with the way it worked. There could have been a couple reasons for that. 1 I don't have a paint booth and 2. I don't paint enough with a sprayer to know exactly how much pressure to use or what other factors to adjust to get it perfect the first time. The finish was a little rough and when I sanded (I used one of those really fine sponge sanding pads that you can get at Harbor Freight 10 in a pack) it I wore through the poly quicker than I was expecting. When you wear throught the surface of the poly your S.O.L. I applied a second coat thinking it might fill in but it didn't. I removed the water based poly and shot it with reqular oil based poly and it worked 100% better.

I don't see why you couldn't use a simi gloss. I personally won't use a high gloss again. My experience tells me that it take a pro to reallly apply it well. My attempts to use high gloss ended with me throwing a quart can away in frustration.

I'm not sure about the original Bakelite finish. It looks like it has some kind of plastic film probably lacquer on it but I think poly gets it about as close as one can get to the original finish. I want to try lacquer some time but it's getting harder to find.

Here's a good writeup on finishes.
http://polyurethanevarnish.com/

Good luck, I hope you'll post some pics of your finished set.

John

Last edited by charokeeroad; 03-30-2011 at 08:52 AM.
Reply With Quote
Audiokarma