View Single Post
  #35  
Old 12-22-2010, 03:41 AM
rcanewvista's Avatar
rcanewvista rcanewvista is offline
VideoKarma Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2007
Posts: 33
I noticed a lot of members here really dont like flatscreens, (and it shouldnt be surprising since this is a vintage tv forum) however I dont understand the arguements against flatscreens besides the issues regarding longevity. I mean, a lot of folks have said that crts are much clearer better colors etc etc...and frankly I dont see it (pun intended). I know this is a subjective issue but I've tried both types of tv's and it seems clear (at least to me) that flatscreens have the advantge in producing a better picture.

Dont get me wrong, I love crts and the technology behind it and I really wish crts would still be produced. In fact the only tv I currently own is a 1968 Maganvox Stereo Theatre combo... all tube color chassis. However, about a year ago, my brother gave me a 50 inch lcd flatscreen as a wedding gift- it was totl with a 1080p picture. At first I told him I didnt want it, but I relented and used it about a year before I finally gave it back... and I must say I was really impressed. The picture was so good, especially from blueray or hd movies that I didnt have much reason to go out to the cinema any more. The same could be said for the hd cable I was receiving- it looked great. I also hooked the tv up to use as a giant computer monitor. Plus I didnt think the tv looked all that bad in the living room, even when it was off (and I like wood console tvs with concealing doors).

When my brother bought a new home, I gave the flatscreen back since I figured he would have better use for it. Now I am back to the Magnavox crt. With a digital converter, I must say the Magnavox does look really sharp and I've impressed most of my guests- who initially didn't believe such an old tv can produce such a great picture. However, beyond the initial wow factor- I can't honestly say that the crt produces a better picture than a flatscreen, simply due to the capabilities of the resolution and size of the picture. Perhaps to some people it is the lack of sharpness that makes the picture seem more realistic? I dunno, and I couldnt figure it out- unless people are biased for sentimental reasons?

Maybe the other members here can tell me what I am missing, since after trying the best of both worlds- a totl crt tv from 1968, and a totl flatscreen tv circa 2009- I'd have to say the 2009 has a better picture hands down. But in terms of styling, longevity and pride of ownership- nothing can beat the Magnavox!
Reply With Quote
Audiokarma