The 5AXP4 will sub for most late 40's round B&W tubes like the 10BP4, 12LP4, 12QP4, 12JP4 etc, it will NOT sub for a mid 50's 21" tube however, the HV is too much for it to handle, it arcs inside, I know this for sure... somehow...
The large neck rectangular tube is an 8YP4 or an 8XP4, can't remember which is which, they will work for the big rectangular tubes.