Phil, I know what you mean. Ive checked everything I know how to check, the only thing that remains is possibly a slightly off frequency local oscilator. That would cause the synchronous demod in the 12AZ7 to go wonky, along with a loss of color.
Wayne, thanks for the tips. My brother did mention that even small value ceramic caps can 'age' over time, and cause frequency dependent circuits to go bad. We'll see what I come up with later today. Gotta go praise the Lord now.