View Single Post
  #5  
Old 05-12-2010, 05:11 PM
Aussie Bloke's Avatar
Aussie Bloke Aussie Bloke is offline
VideoKarma Member
 
Join Date: May 2004
Location: NSW, Australia
Posts: 560
To the average viewer this clip is a superb recreation of the Ed Sullivan Theatre and Billy Joel did an excellent recreation of the 60s Motown sound. To camera engineers and those who know their cameras and studio setups, all the mistakes are very obvious, but it wouldn't worry the average viewer viewing the clip lol.

Anyways from my standpoint the main 2 things that stood out that were incorrect is the control room was more modern than the gear, the TK-14 was paired with a TK-31 on the other side, bit strange, although the Ed Sullivan Show did have a mix of TK-30 and TK-31s in the 50s. Also the pictures on the monitors didn't have the image orthicon tones and halos around bright objects. I know the Marconi MK4s came in, in the early 60s, not sure which date though so in the beginning of the 60s they still used the old TK-30/31s.

Anyhow despite the inaccuracies in recreating the Ed Sullivan Show pointed out, I thought the recreation was still fantastically done, and they went to great efforts to make it look as authentic as possible with having the old cameras with the old CBS logos and getting a guy who looks and sounds like Ed Sullivan to play his part so it was a production well done to my opinion!!!

Following up on Sally's comment, hip-hop duo Outkast did a clip in similar fashion to Billy Joel's entitled "Hey Ya" http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CvKs133Udmk which they recreated an old TV studio setup with old cameras and people watched them on an old 40s TV set. Anyhow the cameras they used was a RCA TK-41 and a TK-60, bit strange to have a mix of B&W and colour cameras for studio work as it will confuse the viewer in wondering if this program is in living colour or not hehehehe. Well I it looks they are shooting the whole show in B&W so they should of used 2 TK-60s instead. Spot all the other obvious mistakes in this clip. I still say this clip was very well done and worth watching. Have to say the lead singer with the long hair and mo looks a lot like keyboardist Billy Beck from 70s funk band Ohio Players.
__________________
AUSSIE AUSSIE AUSSIE!!!!! OI OI OI!!!!!
Reply With Quote
Audiokarma