Quote:
Originally Posted by Robert Grant
Two thoughts why:
The "AC ONLY" warning is on so many things, that manufacturers (who, these days, usually do not speak any English) apply it generically to all plug-in products shipped to North America.
It may also be because of compact fluorescent bulbs, I strongly suspect they won't work with DC, though I have not tried it. Traditional fluorescent systems absolutely will not work with 120 V DC.
You are correct about incandescent bulbs, they work fine on DC, were first used with DC, and (smaller bulbs) are used extensively with DC.
As a sidenote, I thought it quite amusing when I lit a 40W incandescent using the AAx60 alkaline "B" battery I rigged for my Trans-Oceanics.
|
Interesting. I did not realize until now that standard, tubular fluorescent bulbs (I think this may also apply to GE's 37-watt "Circline" circular fluorescent tubes of the '60s, which were used in overhead kitchen lighting fixtures of that era) will not, under any circumstances, work on direct current. The same reasoning may well apply to today's compact fluorescents, which have circuitry in their bases that could be damaged or destroyed if the bulb were to be operated on anything other than AC power.
I bet that "B" battery pack didn't last long when you did your experiment with trying to operate a 40-watt incandescent with it. The battery probably wouldn't have lasted five minutes if you had tried this with, for example, a 75-watt bulb; as for a 100-watt or larger one(!)--well, the thing would light for perhaps ten seconds, then the battery would be totally exhausted.
I didn't realize, either, that incandescent light bulbs were first used on direct-current circuits, although it makes sense since many major US cities had DC electric service in their downtown areas until well into the 1950s, with some buildings having DC for elevator motors, et al. as late as the late '80s. I cannot speak for other cities, but think Cleveland had DC power downtown for years; I'm not sure about the residential areas of the city or the suburbs.
Come to think of it, DC power must have been in use even in some residential areas as late as the 1960s; witness the AC-DC All-American Five table radios, most of which were designed to operate on 115 volts AC or DC. (Most such radios, except those with clocks, were designed to operate on either power source; if you were willing to do without the clock, even clock radios would work on AC or DC.) However, when television arrived, the sets were designed for use on alternating current only, the series-string filament circuits and AC-line-derived B+ supplies in these receivers notwithstanding. I once read in an old TV repair manual (circa 1950s) that the term "AC/DC" does not apply to such TV sets as it does to radios. Series-string TV sets were known as "transformerless" sets, as they were not designed for operation on DC power circuits.