Quote:
Originally Posted by Carmine
High-end, HDTV sets were available for many years with ATSC (digital) tuners. Several people on this forum had them years before the required switch. Why would flagship stations in major markets like LA & NY have been broadcasting a ATSC digital signal for nearly a decade if consumers were "systematically denied" digital tuners?
|
Because of an FCC mandate that
required broadcasters in major markets to construct and operate DTV facilities early.
They knew that their DTV signals were being watched by no one, but did not want to lose their analog licenses, and with it their network affiliation and cable must-carry status, if they refused to comply.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Carmine
But I didn't. Because although they did exist (The RCA f-38310 is an example) there was nothing to watch on a digital subchannel, and the dual tuners only came in $5000 TVs! What do you suppose the extra cost of a digital tuner was, at the manufacturer level? Less than $10 for a board and some ICs.
:
|
Like you said, on very high-end TV sets (likely sold by high-end home theater specialists that did not sell cable or satellite subscriptions).
The big box stores did (and still do) act as agents for subscription TV services, getting a cut for every new customer they sign up. A customer who could have bought a digital tuner with their set had a chance of saying "no thanks" when the salesman pushed a cable or satellite contract.
So the big boxes told the manufacturers "Don't ship us anything with a digital tuner"
Quote:
Originally Posted by Carmine
You can bet that sometime in 2008, the lobbyists pulled strings to get that mandate going... "Tell those sheep it will prevent another 9/11 if we get rid of analog TV, yeah, they'll be begging you to do it!"
And we did. 
|
Actually, the tuner mandate (47CFR15.117) was actually passed well before 2008 (2005, IIRC), with the largest sets mandated first, then, any device with a TV tuner, including VCRs and DVD recorders, manufactured 3/1/2007 or later, (TV sets still in inventory could be sold after this date. In the case of VCRs, most complied by eliminating the tuner altogether).