Is this the north side shop you were thinking of? Cole's on Lincoln Ave.
This is an older image I found on their website, the last time I want by there, the Admiral sign and the hanging sign over the door were still there and lit, but the sings on the side had been covered up with something newer.
The signs look really nice at night.
My parents bought a new stove and dishwasher there about 7 years ago, at that time everything was still done by hand with big manufacturer's catalog books and typewriters, no computers in the store. Really nice people.