I have a "rooftop" style antenna that I bought 6 years ago.
It is in my attic instead of the roof as I am in a townhouse, It worked great for analog and it continues to work great for digital too!
I have a four-way splitter/booster on it as I have cable runs to each room in the house.
I have noticed that I can get great reception regardless of the way it is aimed, perhaps digital is less directional than analog
Anyway, I had my doubts but it continues to work great!!
Good luck!