View Single Post
  #43  
Old 08-14-2009, 12:14 PM
Jeffhs's Avatar
Jeffhs Jeffhs is offline
<----Zenith C845
 
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Fairport Harbor, Ohio (near Lake Erie)
Posts: 4,035
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tom_Ryan View Post
Are you sure about that? Radar detectors are illegal to use (possibly own) in some States ...perhaps because speeding can harm someone if there's an accident? While I can't imagine harming someone by simply watching an old analog TV set? ...please correct me, I could be wrong ...it might offend some politician if they can't be seen in the glory of 1080p which is completely counter intutive to Governments generally thought to be slow, prone to error, lacking resolution, grey area policies or taking a black & white stand on most issues. I still remember when I was a wee tyke my Dad's Philco 41 radio had a label on the back of it stating that it was unlawful to operate without a license. Apparently that law fizzled. Still have the radio packed away somewhere. In any event, I'm sure I won't vote for anyone that raises taxes or abolishes the ownership of analog TV sets or there use! Nay, not me.

Keep in mind, we live in an age where the Government tried but failed to keep out of the public domain some of the strongest and most durable public key ciphers to protect data introduced by the computer industry. So, I think the whole argument of the demise of analog, while very real, is being driven by big business and greedy Governments looking for ways to collect tax. The wireless industry in America is partly responsible for driving the FCC to consolidate spectrum which generates billions of dollars in Government revenue. Digital TV is more spectrum efficient compared to analog broadcast standards - that means more stations per MHz and more taxes. It's all about money. It's not about mom and dad needing higher resoltuion of anything. Even an old GE Portacolor is good enough for me! Regardless of the outcome, collectors of old TV sets will likely still be able to enjoy their use. Ganted it may be more inconvenience becuase of required convertor boxes or agile modulators to generate the necessary RF signals. Hey, then again ....this can be also be a technical hobby, right?
I guess I should have said "the government cannot declare analog TV receivers illegal...yet", although I don't see why they would even try to ban them; they probably wouldn't have much luck getting such legislation passed, since there are so many analog televisions still in use. They are all some people have or can afford; let's face it, analog CRT TVs still make better pictures than most flat panels, although there are some very large FPs from reputable manufacturers that produce excellent pictures, comparable to any good CRT set.

It is in fact against the law to own or use radar detectors in the state of Virginia (one cannot purchase such devices there for just that reason); this ban has been in effect there for years or decades. I don't know, however, whether or not any other state in this country ever banned (or is currently banning) the devices.

I don't see why the government would have any reason to ban analog televisions. They are set to ban sales of incandescent light bulbs in 2012 or '13, but that is also for a reason--to save energy. This is also the reason for the government's "cash for clunkers" program, although this program is entirely voluntary for the time being--if someone wants to keep his or her treasured classic car(s) for years they can do so.

Our government has no power whatsoever to tell us what kind of TV set we can use, even though it is in fact impossible nowadays to purchase new-in-box analog sets due to a law passed two years ago, banning the sale in the US of such sets. Remember as well that cable operators are not bound by FCC rules to transmit digital signals; as another person posted, either here or in another thread, cable companies are free to send analog signals over their cables forever if they so choose.

Time-Warner Cable still has full-analog service available for people who do not yet have digital TVs; I think it is a law all cable companies must abide by (that they must provide analog service indefinitely for subscribers with older sets), and will be for some time, as there are literally millions of analog televisions still in use. That ridiculous scenario perpetrated some years ago in which everyone in the US, with no exceptions, would throw out their old analog TVs en masse in 2006 and get digital flat-panels because analog sets would no longer operate (2006 was then the proposed analog shutoff date) was just a scare tactic, calculated to boost sales of flat-panel HDTVs.

While it is true that even today standard analog TVs will not work without cable or a converter box, these options are available today (converter boxes were not available in 2006 and many cable companies were still 100-percent analog at that time as well), and in fact cable companies are required by law to provide analog service if the subscriber(s) need it--and as I said, a great many people still do rely on analog cable, as they may live in areas where rabbit ears or even outdoor antennas don't work well and still have "old fashioned" analog TVs.

Your dad's Philco radio must have been an export model, if it had a warning label stating its use without a license is illegal; some European countries do, however, have (or have had) laws stating that radio and television receivers must be licensed.

To the best of my knowledge, there has never been a law here in the US requiring people to license their radio receivers. I do know, however, that there was a law against listening to shortwave in this country during World War II; in fact, radio repair shops were required by that very law to disable the shortwave bands, if any, on any set that came in for repairs during that time.
__________________
Jeff, WB8NHV

Collecting, restoring and enjoying vintage Zenith radios since 2002

Zenith. Gone, but not forgotten.

Last edited by Jeffhs; 08-14-2009 at 01:06 PM.
Reply With Quote