Quote:
Originally Posted by mech986
EDIT: so essentially, even though there was not a specific mention of nuclear war in TOS's future, it did not specifically exclude it.
Regards,
Bart, EMH
|
Thanks for filling in some of the gaps. I still have a problem with their version of trek history.
In Space Seed, kirk says to spock, something along the lines of, "i wonder why there is no mention of this flight (DY-100) in the history tapes?" Spock replies, "Captain, would you let a war weary population know that 30 of their supermen are missing?"
Now if there was a full scale nuke war with a side order of Eugenics and Bio warfare, and for dessert they will be having a total collapse of governments, oh and the check comes to 250,000,000 dead, do you think spock would have used the phrase "war weary"? I don't.
Oh and if did happen as the TNG episode says, do you think the remnants of civilization would care about 30 supermen blasting off into space? I think the answer is, "no".
Then there are a couple of other episodes, where they go back in time, circa 1969, and no mention amoung themselves about this upcoming devestation? In fact why was there never any mention of this planet wide nuke war in TOS? Something like that is bound to have come up at some point. you don't forget something like that. We have people today, who still debate the cause of the The Great War, and that pales in comparison...
Now on to the TNG pilot episode. If as you say Roddenberry is writing the pilot with the Reagan era and nuclear buildup in mind. Too bad! Roddenberry has already written his trek history in TOS. He can not change it, just to suit his political whims.
I do not have a problem with a tactical nukes being used. In fact I never ruled that out in the first place.
I am not referencing anything from Enterprise, Voyager, or DS9. That would be revisionist history, if Farpoint is indeed a blunder. I am speaking strictly from a TOS reference.
Then there is the Warp capable Phoenix in First Contact. How was he suppose to return to earth, once he made the maiden voyage. Seems to me, he is asking a lot of an converted ICBM...