View Single Post
  #6  
Old 01-25-2009, 03:40 AM
AndyMack's Avatar
AndyMack AndyMack is offline
VideoKarma Member
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Albany, NY
Posts: 50
The converter boxes do not offer the faster refresh rates that the upper tier LCD sets have now. For good rendition of fast motion (i.e. sports), the typical digital artifacts that appear at the 60hz refresh rate mostly disappear at 120hz. Since DTV STB's convert everything to an equivalent of 480i, the picture is literally crushed to death (high compression ratio).

After watching OTA DTV on my 32" LCD set for the last few years, I've [sadly] grown used to it. The STB's on the other hand, offer a much lesser quality picture. I hooked one up to my LCD to gauge the difference between the TV tuner and the STB and was shocked to see how much - even on 480i source material - is lost thru the RF modulator. The line outputs offer a little better picture, but still really shabby compared to what the Tv's built-in tuner can render. That said, you really can't expect much from 480i. It's actually less sharp than a good NTSC signal. We have RTN on one of our DTV subchannels here, and seeing those old programs on DTV is horrid, as the broadcast format is very unforgiving to poor quality video sources. (RTN doesn't exactly have the greatest copies of their programs on hand, either) In contrast, my old DVD player has a DTV tuner built in, and when hooked up via the composites to a compatible CRT set, it looks pretty decent. Not sure why the older unit outperforms the newer STB's.
720 & 1080 on the other hand outperforms NTSC by a mile, assuming that you can overcome reception issues. If the weather is calm, I get great reception from 30 miles out. If the wind is blowing, then my UHF's are all futzed up (too many trees/forest around here). In contrast, my brother has DTV via cable, and the compression the cable company adds to save bandwidth is very noticeable, esp. on 1080i programming. Maybe if they ditched 20 or 30 channels that nobody ever watches they could offer up the local HD shows at the quality they're broadcast at.

I like the fact that analog broadcasting was still usable even in weak signal instances (and more easily DX'ed - another hobby going bye-bye for me), but I don't think I'd give up my widescreen HDTV to go back to NTSC on a daily basis, especially for movies, sports in HD and anything graphics heavy like the local HD newscasts.

I think one of the things we have to admit here is that unlike NTSC, we're seeing a broadcast format that has the capability of exceeding the source material's quality. In other words, with NTSC the video at the station was always better than what went out thru the transmitter, and the comparatively low resolution of CRT sets hid most of that quality loss. With OTA digital, what is seen at the station's master control is exactly what is seen on the LCD/Plasma screen at the other end.
Reply With Quote