View Single Post
  #53  
Old 08-26-2008, 08:15 PM
NowhereMan 1966's Avatar
NowhereMan 1966 NowhereMan 1966 is offline
Slave to 1 Cat
 
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Tiltonsville, OH
Posts: 888
Quote:
Originally Posted by ChrisW6ATV View Post
The trouble with "market-based" solutions is that most people are far too short-sighted to ever choose what is good in the long term, and many things (like digital TV) require mass adoption to get their costs down to compete with and eventually surpass the old standards. In other cases, it is not just cost reduction that drives changes and government mandates. Without laws, would we have mandatory air bags, seat belts, or numerous other safety features in all of our cars? Most likely not; relatively few people go shopping based on those features, or fuel mileage (until recently), etc. The same was true for UHF tuners on TV sets; they were an extra-cost option (and therefore rare) until required by law, thus making UHF TV stations more viable, bringing many more on the air, and opening a far wider choice of programming to people who otherwise (and formerly) would not have chosen the "extra cost" UHF tuner.

If we "let the market decide", then all over-the-air TV will go away since 85% of the U.S. public has satellite or cable TV, and the remaining people are assumed to be lower income than those who pay for their TV reception. Digital TV, and its increased channel capacity (which means more ad sales), is going to help keep OTA TV available as an option, not hinder it, but most people will not choose it unless "they have to right now". Just look at all the nay-sayers on this forum alone, and we are more technically inclined and adept than the average public.
Yeah, I guess you do have good points, I mean there is a good side to DTV. If I'm ever too poor for cable, at least I have more choices than before with over the air TV. I could always watch one of the local PBS subchannels that always broadcasts Pittsburgh and Pennsylvania history by a local named Rick Sebak or go to RTN with all the old shows from the 1950's to the 1980's. I might be looking at that now being unemployed righ now and having to cut back. Myself, I think standard def is OK, it doesn't matter as long as the program is good, but that is my take. Back in the day, I liked how you have some choices on over the air TV, at least during the afternoons, the Pittsburgh station ran cartoons, so did Steubenville, Ohio, but Youngstown ran movies in the afternoon. When movies like "Planet of the Apes," "Matt Helm," or "A Man Like Flint" came on, we were in hog heaven. Today, it's all Dr. Phil, Oprah and so on, so bland, so homoginized. If we get an ION affiliate, it would be perfect, but at least I have PBS and RTN.

I might be delving into politics a little but there are too many who believe the free market is the end all, yes, it is a tool, an excellent one, but I guess it should not be applied to everything.

I never thought of it that way, maybe DTV will energize over the air TV, I mean when we watch RTN, it is over the air, not on cable.
__________________
Mom (1938 - 2013) - RIP, I miss you
Spunky, (1999 - 2016) - RIP, pretty girl!
Rascal, (2007 - 2021) RIP, miss you very much
Reply With Quote