View Single Post
  #39  
Old 08-24-2008, 06:25 AM
Carmine's Avatar
Carmine Carmine is offline
...enjoys spaghetti.
 
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Detroit area
Posts: 1,612
Quote:
Originally Posted by ChrisW6ATV View Post
The trouble with "market-based" solutions is that most people are far too short-sighted to ever choose what is good in the long term,
Respectfully because I respect most of your postings, and do not wish this to come off as a flame-war, I have to say that this statement comes off as incredibly arrogant. Market-based solutions may take longer than what you would prefer, but ultimately produce the only fair result. There is a place for government mandates (general welfare/safety issues) but this is neither.

Quote:
and many things (like digital TV) require mass adoption to get their costs down to compete with and eventually surpass the old standards.
I think you are conveniently ignoring the most obvious comparison to the current digital/analog changeover, color-to-B&W. By mandating compatibility, the FCC ensured that color TV broadcasts/receivers would continue to improve in terms of both reliability and cost by forcing them compete with B&W broadcasts/receivers. Had they ruled the existing B&W system "end" at some date, there would have been very little motivation for manufacturers to make the color TV improvements that came between 1954-1964.

There also would have been the enormous taxpayer cost of about $500+ for each "coupon" to purchase a color TV. (Although I'm sure RCA would have loved the idea of the government using taxpayer money to buy everybody a new TV set.)

Quote:
In other cases, it is not just cost reduction that drives changes and government mandates. Without laws, would we have mandatory air bags, seat belts, or numerous other safety features in all of our cars? Most likely not; relatively few people go shopping based on those features, or fuel mileage (until recently), etc.
First of all, government doesn't "invent" anything. Therefore they cannot mandate anything that hasn't already been developed by private industry. I can tell you with all certainty that we WOULD in fact have air-bags in cars, circa 2008 without government mandate. Brief history lesson:

Air-bags were first conceived long before seat-belts became commonplace in vehicles. I believe the original automotive patent dates to 1948, but the limited deployment technology of the time prevented serious research until the late 60s. By this time, they were seen as a replacement for the cumbersome seatbelts which most people did not use, not supplemental restraints (SRS) as they are today. This was entirely market-based, giving customers a passive, non-intrusive way to avoid eating the windshield in a crash.

Had the government stepped in, let's say in 1960, and made seat-belt usage the law-of-the-land as it is today, what motivation would have existed for further air-bag research? Certainly it wouldn't have been a priority, because whether you drove a $6000 Buick or a $2000 Chevy, you'd still have to wear an uncomfortable belt per government edict. Without a mandate, there is still motivation to research a comfortable, passive restraint system. Here is an airbag in the aforementioned Buick... Only market forces caused this to appear within its 70s green-velour interior...




As I mentioned earlier, there is a place for government mandates. Staying within the realm of automotive for a moment (since there are few welfare/safety issues regarding a television standards) an example of a justified mandate would be emissions standards. The difference being that automotive emissions effect the entire population, unlike seatbelts/airbags which effect individual safety. Even in this example, the government didn't invent squat... Most all innovation in this area, including technology still used today all over the world, came from GM/Chrysler and Ford (more/less in that order BTW). The necessity for government mandate (action) comes because emission equipment of that era reduced drivability and increased costs. No single manufacturer could afford the resulting loss in sales, so it had to be mandated uniformly. Smaller anti-smog innovations, such as the PCV system did occur throughout the 60s without mandate.


Quote:
If we "let the market decide", then all over-the-air TV will go away since 85% of the U.S. public has satellite or cable TV, and the remaining people are assumed to be lower income than those who pay for their TV reception.
The 85% number doesn't include secondary sets. The low-income argument doesn't wash either, if only because every rental tenant who has ever helped pay the mortgage for a home I own has always had cable and a larger TV then I own. (OK just kidding here, I know that's anecdotal.) But is it better to market to 50 millionaires or 500,000 people who make $50K a year? Most marketers would say the latter.

But really if this end-of-OTA argument really held up, why haven't they already gone away? That 85% number has probably been constant for at least 15-years. There is nothing preventing an OTA station from making a deal with a cable provider and shutting down their transmitter. At that point, they cease to be FCC regulated and don't have to pay for transmitter costs. Somebody else can buy the license.

Obviously there is a reason to broadcast over the air, but no reason beyond government fiat (via lobbyist corruption) to shutdown analog.
__________________
From Captain Video, 1/4/2007
"It seems that Italian people are very prone to preserve antique stuff."
Reply With Quote