View Single Post
  #38  
Old 06-18-2008, 04:57 PM
MudPuppy176 MudPuppy176 is offline
Banned
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Posts: 11
Quote:
Originally Posted by 70salesguy View Post
The Soviet built RBMK units produce electricity and plutonium. The units at Chernobyl were (are) RBMKs and are water cooled graphite rod moderated slow neutron reactors. The US reactors that were used to produce plutonium for weapons are also graphite rod moderated slow neutron reactors, but in the US we do not attempt to produce electricity with these reactors.

Most commercial power reactors in the US are light water cooled and moderated and as a result are far less dangerous to operate.

The Soviet RBMKs were designed to be refueled on line.
Partially correct, mostly incomplete. ALL reactors produce plutonium (from uranium). None produce "weapons grade" plutonium. It takes a great deal of refining to extract pure plutonium from "spent" fuel. US commercial power reactors get around half their power output from plutonium at the end of a fuel cycle. Using graphite versus water as a moderator doesn't make RBMK's unsafe. The poor design (positive void coefficient) certainly does. Canadian CANDU's are also refueled online, another non safety issue.