View Single Post
  #37  
Old 06-15-2008, 10:58 PM
RussinOhio's Avatar
RussinOhio RussinOhio is offline
AK Member
 
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: Westlake, Ohio
Posts: 120
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr. Lin View Post
I'm surprised so many people really didn't like this movie, I thought it was great, although the abrupt ending sort of comes out of left field - I was able to appreciate that much more when I thought about what happened in the movie afterwards, but at the time I was annoyed just because I wanted to see more.

I'm not surprised that American viewers are disappointed that the "villain" won in the end. I've always been frustrated by the shallowness of our culture in that regard, it's such a cliche to always have a happy ending, it's unrealistic, and it's been done to death. But like others here have said, this movie is art, which life imitates, right?


I need to see it again myself.
I had no idea it was based upon a book for one thing. I was not so much expecting nor wanting a happy ending, as you have stated the ending just did not satisfy me. Although I could not stand that the structure of the story mandated that the wife must be killed by the hitman....I wanted MORE reaction from T.L Jones charactor in relation to it. Not for him to just stare out a window reciting a memory.....then fade out to credits.

I did not nor would I want his charactor to go "Dirty Harry" on the bad guy....I just wanted more meat! The last hour & ending needed more exposition IMHO. Especially that most (like myself) were not even aware a novel excisted in the first place.

Maybe I'd like the book better.

Russ
Reply With Quote