Quote:
Originally Posted by kbmuri
I bought a Space Command 400 remote from that ePay place:
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll...m=330223873934
Completely mechanical, pressing each spring-loaded button causes a striker to ping a corresponding tuning fork.
I struck each button into the mike of an audio spectrum analyzer. Results were as follows:
Channel-higher ping -- 9.04 KHz.
Channel-lower ping -- 8.33 kHz
Sound/Mute ping -- 8.07 kHz
Volume-On/Off ping -- 7.66 kHz.
(Measurements taken at curve peak).
There's a pretty good (but not great) correspondence between 5X these values and your values. Obviously your remote is truly "ultrasonic". Mine is quite audible. I remember urban legends that dogs used to be able to change channels on these TVs by barking. Maybe that's why they upped the frequency (when electronics advances made it possible).
I wonder what the "spec" frequencies are for the 400. Does my remote need tuned? How do you tune a mechanical version?
Related fun here: http://www.audiokarma.org/forums/sho...39#post1792639
|
I suspect your spectrum analyzer does not go up to ultrasonic frequencies? The spectrum content you recorded could be the damped "tink" you hear on the mechanical remotes - and/or either a subharmonic or distortion in your microphone. I believe the actual frequency in use would be higher and purer [edit: - and louder - much too loud and annoying if it really worked at those lower frequencies] , but I'm just guessing. At one time I built a mixer to convert the ultrasonic down to audible frequencies - it was interesting to hear what produced loud ultrasonic vibrations.
I had a 75 Heathkit with ultrasonic remote. The dog could turn it on and off, which I discovered when I came home to find it on. However, it wasn't his collar or tags or the remote at all - just his big tail hitting the big on/off buttons on the front.