View Single Post
  #54  
Old 11-25-2007, 04:48 PM
Fisherdude's Avatar
Fisherdude Fisherdude is offline
The Golden Age of Hi-Fi
 
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Lewiston, ID
Posts: 324
Take a look at where the 10' viewing distance line intersects with the 50" screen size. It's right on the green line where "full benefit of 720p (vs 480p) is visible".

This means that at 10', if you put a 50" 480p set and a 50" 720p set side by side, the difference would be dramatic. The 720p set would have a noticeably better picture. However, if you put a 50" 720p and 1080p set side by side, you really wouldn't be able to see much difference. If you moved closer than 10', you'd start to see the 1080p set start to look better than the 720p.

In order for a 1080p set to look as good as it could at 10', you'd need an 80" screen.

I know this may not sound logical, and it may be hard to grasp the concept of what degrees of arc the human eye is capable of resolving, so maybe an extreme example will make it clear. If you put a 50" 720p set and a 50" 1080p set side by side, and viewed the pictures from a distance of 50', obviously you wouldn't be able to tell any difference between the two whatsoever. If you started walking slowly toward the two tv's, eventually you would get close enough that you could juuuuust barely tell that the picture on the 1080p was starting to look juuuuust a little better. That's what the chart is showing.

In my viewing room, the couch and the tv are 18' apart. What does that mean in my case? In order to get the maximum benefit of 1080p, I would need a 120" screen. Not gonna happen. So, that means that in my case (probably a 46"-50"), 720p will be just fine.

Otoh, if I think about what's happening in the marketplace, i.e. that 1080p is becoming more and more common, and prices continue to drop as they eventually do with every new technology, I'll probably end up with a 1080p set anyway. It just won't really make that much difference in the picture that I'm actually viewing on a 50" set at 18'.
__________________
I may be growing older, but I refuse to grow up.

Last edited by Fisherdude; 11-25-2007 at 04:52 PM.
Reply With Quote