I once challenged my son and his friend Paul (they were 9 years old at the time) to watch Mario Bava's "Planet of the Vampires." It's a very creepy, eerie and atmospheric film and purportedly was an influence for Ridley Scott's "Alien." They were pretty creeped out by the movie...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planet_of_the_Vampires
The movie that scared ME the most when I was that age was the original version of "The Haunted," esp. the breathing doors.