View Single Post
  #8  
Old 06-01-2007, 07:58 PM
Einar72's Avatar
Einar72 Einar72 is offline
Chasin roundies since '79
 
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Federal Way, Washington
Posts: 936
Quote:
Originally Posted by waltchan
Which is better, tube-chassis or solid-state? What are the pros and cons in each?
Both have their followers. Tube receivers, properly designed ones, that is, have equivalent performance to their SS counterparts - when comparing similarly-equipped chassis. Where SS receivers take the lead, IMHO, is in technical advances not present during the heyday of tubes, such as comb filters. Maybe Pete could come up with a tube-type comb filter for the CT-100!

Tube receivers suffer from cumulative heat damage, especially those with 1950's peanut-brittle PCBA's, and can have all the faults possible in one tube times a dozen on up, per the tube count. Tubes can age rapidly if worked too hard. SS units also suffer from heat, but to a lesser degree, and have more current-surge issues that arise when the design-inherent large capacitors age poorly. BAM! SNAP! POW!

One issue unknown when SS units became popular is longevity of the devices, both physically and commercially. When the jungle IC in a TV becomes unobtanium, is that ever so frustrating! It's been 20-plus years since I saw a color portable returned unrepairable due to no replacement flyback being available. If no original is to be had, you face a different story since the once-crowded flyback-replacement field has become a ghost story, and modern economics dictates NOT supporting older products all too soon after production ends! Germanium-era units are the worst, since silicon vendors ran away years ago from most OEM replacements.

But there is nothing, I mean nothing like the magical aroma wafting up from inside the cabinet of an old tube monster, like my first - a '52 Sylvania 21-incher! Stick your nose in and enjoy!
Reply With Quote